Dual-Hop AF Relaying Systems in Mixed
Nakagami-m and Rician Links
Samy S. Soliman, Student member, IEEE, and Norman C. Beaulieu, Fellow, IEEE
AITF Wireless Communications Laboratory
University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta, T6G2V4 Canada
{soliman, beaulieu}@icoremail.ece.ualberta.ca
Abstract—New, exact closed-form expressions for the prob-
ability density function (PDF) and the cumulative distribution
function (CDF) are derived for the instantaneous received end-to-
end signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) of dual-hop amplify-and-forward
(AF) relaying systems operating over mixed Nakagami-m and
Rician fading links. The expressions are used to obtain exact
integral solutions for the ergodic capacity and the average symbol
error probability as well as an exact closed-form solution for
the outage probability of dual-hop AF systems operating over
mixed links. The results obtained represent the first exact results
for the cases of composite Nakagami-m/Rician fading links.
The exact performance metrics are compared to performance
bounds in the literature, and it is shown that the performance
bounds are not tight for medium ranges of SNR. The effects of
fading parameters on the system performance are studied. It is
shown that the limiting slopes of the average error probability
and outage probability curves are not affected by the fading
parameters, however, SNR gains are achieved by increasing the
fading parameter. Moreover, it is shown also that an increase
in the Rician parameter, K, results in a notable SNR gain in
the system performance, while an increase in the Nakagami-
m parameter, m, has diminishing returns and gives negligible
improvement in the system performance in some instances.
Index Terms—Amplify-and-forward, average symbol error
probability, cooperative networks, dual-hop relaying, ergodic
capacity, mixed links, outage probability.
I. I NTRODUCTION
Wireless cooperative communication has become an impor-
tant subject for study because it promises an advancement in
the quantity as well as the quality of services provided to
users [1]–[10]. In [1], the authors presented an approximation
for the end-to-end received signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) using
the harmonic mean of two independent exponential random
variables in order to estimate the average error probability and
outage probability of dual-hop AF relaying systems operating
over Rayleigh fading links. In [2], the work was extended to
the case of multihop transmission over Nakagami-m fading
channels, and the authors obtained an approximation to the
system outage probability. Since then, many publications, such
as [3], [4] have used the direct harmonic mean approxima-
tion of the individual per hop instantaneous SNRs to obtain
performance bounds. However, it has been shown that such
bounds are neither tight for small-to-moderate values of SNR,
nor for Nakagami-m fading channels for large values of m
[5], [7]. In [5], an approximation has been proposed that has
the same computational complexity as previous bounds in the
literature, while being more accurate, especially for small-to-
medium values of SNR. The new approximation gives more
accurate prediction of the exact performance than the bounds.
In [6], [7], a new analytical approach, the generalized
transformed characteristic function (GTCF) method, was pro-
posed to obtain the first exact results published for the outage
probability, ergodic capacity and the average symbol error
probability of multihop AF relaying systems operating over
general fading channels. An important result shown in [6], [7]
is that as the number of hops increases, the ergodic capacity
of the system decreases although other performance metrics
of the systems are enhanced.
In the following, we study dual-hop AF networks and obtain
exact solutions for the performance metrics of dual-hop AF
systems operating over mixed Nakagami-m and Rician fading
channels [8]–[10]. Previously, the authors in [8] obtained an
exact expression for the outage probability of dual-hop AF
systems operating over mixed Rayleigh and Rician fading
channels; however, that exact expression was not used to
obtain other performance metrics. Instead, the authors used an
approximation of the end-to-end SNR to obtain the average
error probability of the system. The authors also presented
a lower bound to the average error probability based on
approximating the end-to-end SNR by the minimum value of
the individual links fading SNRs. In [9], the authors studied
also the case of mixed Rayleigh and Rician fading chan-
nels for dual-hop, fixed gain relaying systems, and obtained
infinite-series representations for the outage probability and
the average bit error probability of these systems. The case
of dual-hop AF systems with mixed Nakagami-m and Rician
fading links was studied in [10]. The authors in [10] also
used the approximation used in [8], due to its mathematical
tractability, to approximate the outage probability and the
average error probability of the proposed system. Note that the
results presented in [8] and [10] are based on an approximation
for the end-to-end SNR and are not exact.
In this paper, we derive exact closed-form expressions
for the PDF and the CDF of the end-to-end SNR of dual-
hop, variable gain AF relaying systems operating over mixed
Nakagami-m and Rician fading channels and we obtain the
first exact analytical results for the average error probability,
outage probability and ergodic capacity of such dual-hop AF
systems. The most important differences between the work
presented here and previous literature are: 1) The closed-form
GC'12 Workshop: The 7th IEEE International Workshop on Heterogeneous, Multi-Hop, Wireless and Mobile Networks
978-1-4673-4941-3/12/$31.00 ©2012 IEEE 447