REVI SI TI NG THE CONCEPT OF
( OBJECTI VE) AUTHENTI CI TY
Wendy Hillman
The University of Queensland, Brisbane, Australia
w.hillman1@uq.edu.au
ABSTRACT
The concept of authenticity has been a hallmark in the sociology of tourism literature
since it was first used by Dean MacCannell in his seminal works on tourism studies
(1973; 1976). Authenticity has come to be defined in many ways, but has now evolved
into a concept some would argue has become passé (Olsen 2007). This paper discusses
the background to authenticity, its beginnings and foundations and provides various
definitions of the idea from the 1970s to current, twenty-first century thinking. The
background and arguments from noted authors on the subject, such as MacCannell
(1973; 1976), Urry (1995), Pearce and Moscardo (1985), Littrell, Anderson and Brown
(1993) and Sharpley (1994) have all been reviewed in this paper. These authors’
arguments are counter-balanced by the current theorising on authenticity, where authors
such as Wang (1999), Cohen (2007), Olsen (2007) and Pearce (2007) are examined. I
believe however, that objective authenticity still has a place within the sociology of
tourism theories. It will continue to be an enduring concept that will emerge and evolve
alongside more postmodern concepts. I, for one, will continue to use and embrace the
original ideas as suggested by MacCannell (1973; 1976).
1 I NTRODUCTI ON
As tourism has now become a central element of western economies, it is now
recognised that people need travel in order to seek out new experiences and ways of life
for themselves. Travel is seen as a mark of affluence and status, and only people with
little money, the old and infirm, and very young children do not travel. The status and
experience of travel, particularly to 'exotic' destinations, gives a 'value' and worth to
those who have achieved this level of western prosperity. The following paper
concerning authenticity within the scope of tourism brings together some highly
interesting and salient issues relevant to the canon of sociology. I have based much of
my paper on the work of Dean MacCannell (1976) and his book, The Tourist: A New
Theory of the Leisure Class.
According to the many of the early tourism scholars of the 1970-1990s, the most salient
concept at the centre of any research investigating the experience of tourists is that of
authenticity or verisimilitude. Urry amplifies this by arguing
A particular issue is that of authenticity. It is argued especially by MacCannell
that what tourists seek is the 'authentic', but that this is necessarily unsuccessful
since those being gazed upon come to construct artificial sites which keep the
inquisitive tourist away ... Tourist spaces are thus organised around what he
calls 'staged authenticity' (Urry 1995: 140).
Many other writers and researchers have argued that the prominent issue is the fact that
many tourists are indifferent to authenticity and that this may explain their perceptions
of their experiences (Pearce and Moscardo 1985: 158). MacCannell suggests that
contemporary tourists who experience alienation through their daily working lives, pursue
authenticity, through their journeys and holidays, to return home with an experience of a