322 THE NATIONAL MEDICAL JOURNAL OF INDIA VOL. 26, NO. 6, 2013
Original Articles
Post Graduate Institute of Medical Education and Research,
Chandigarh 160012, India
RAVINDER AHLAWAT*, ANIL K. GUPTA, R.K. SHARMA
Department of Hospital Administration
VIVEK KUMAR*, VIVEKANAND JHA Department of Nephrology
MUKUT MINZ Department of Renal Transplant Surgery
VIVEKANAND JHA Department of Translational and Regenerative
Medicine
* Contributed equally to the manuscript
Correspondence to VIVEKANAND JHA; vjha@pginephro.org
© The National Medical Journal of India 2013
Attitude and knowledge of healthcare workers in critical
areas towards deceased organ donation in a public sector
hospital in India
RAVINDER AHLAWAT*, VIVEK KUMAR*, ANIL K. GUPTA, R.K. SHARMA, MUKUT MINZ,
VIVEKANAND JHA
ABSTRACT
Background. The attitude of healthcare workers towards
organ donation can either facilitate or hinder the process of
organ donation. We assessed the attitude of healthcare workers
employed in intensive or emergency care units of our hospital
towards organ donation, and the influence of various factors
on willingness for self-organ donation after death.
Methods. All doctors, paramedical workers, nursing staff
and other staff members working in six distinct intensive or
emergency care units in the hospital were requested to fill a
completely anonymous, voluntary and self-administered
questionnaire. Younger individuals, women and nurses
constituted a majority of the study population.
Results. The questionnaire completion rate was 99%.
About 55% of the study population were agreeable to
donating organs after death and 27% were undecided. The
factors that positively influenced their willingness to donate
organs after death were favourable attitude of the spouse,
religious beliefs supporting organ donation, knowledge of
hospital’s organ transplant programme, personal experience
of the organ donation scenario, having ever donated blood or
involvement in social activities, willingness to become an eye
donor and willingness to become a living kidney donor.
Conclusion. A largely favourable attitude towards organ
donation was seen in our study population. However, the
study reflects incomplete knowledge leading to confusion and
thus, desire to know more among participants with respect to
various aspects regarding organ donation. The factors identified
that positively influence decisions regarding organ donation
can be used as direct interventions.
Natl Med J India 2013;26:322–6
INTRODUCTION
Kidney transplantation is superior to dialysis in terms of survival,
quality of life and cost of therapy,
1,2
and permits thousands of
people with end-stage organ failure to enjoy a relatively normal
life. It is the most viable long-term renal replacement option in
large parts of the developing world including India.
3
An
overwhelming majority of kidneys come from living donors, as
the deceased donor programme is still in infancy and faces
multiple barriers.
4
The deceased organ donation rates in India—which vary in
different parts—have been estimated to be 0.08 per million
population per year.
5
It has been suggested that sustained industrial
growth, infrastructure support and higher rates of literacy in the
southern and western regions of India are supportive to the growth
of deceased donor programmes.
6
Our centre runs one of the oldest
and biggest renal transplant programmes in a public sector hospital
in northern India, with about 170 transplants every year. Deceased
donation at our centre constituted 5.2% of the total renal transplants
done from January 2010 to April 2011. In contrast, deceased
donor renal transplants constituted about 14% of all renal
transplants done at a centre in western India.
7
Recently, our centre
has also started a liver transplant programme.
Awareness programmes, personal beliefs and experiences of
prior contact with healthcare services influence individual and
societal attitudes and awareness regarding organ donation. In
India, consent of the next of kin is mandatory before organs can
be recovered from a deceased donor. The attitudes of healthcare
workers who closely interact with the family of the deceased can
influence their decision.
8
It has been suggested that the low
conversion rate of potential organ donors to actual donors is
perhaps due to the indifferent attitude of staff working in these
critical care areas. Therefore, it becomes important to assess the
knowledge and attitude of healthcare personnel towards organ
donation.
We conducted this study to assess the knowledge and attitude