Long-Length Titania Nanotubes Obtained by High-Voltage
Anodization and High-Intensity Ultrasonication for Superior Capacity
Electrode
Jose ́ R. Gonza ́ lez,
†
Ricardo Alca ́ ntara,
†,
* Francisco Nacimiento,
†
Gregorio F. Ortiz,
†
Jose ́ L. Tirado,
†
Ekaterina Zhecheva,
‡
and Radostina Stoyanova
‡
†
Laboratorio de Química Inorga ́ nica, Campus Universitario de Rabanales, Edificio C3, Universidad de Có rdoba, 14071 Có rdoba,
Spain
‡
Institute of General and Inorganic Chemistry, Bulgarian Academy of Sciences, Acad. G. Bonchev Str. Bldg. 11, 1113 Sofia, Bulgaria
ABSTRACT: To modify the morphology and electrochemical properties of the
resulting titanium oxide layer, we have applied high-intensity ultrasonication
during the potentiostatic anodization of metallic titanium, and the applied voltage
and anodizing time has been changed. The influence of the imposed voltage,
anodizing time, and ultrasonication on the nanotubes growth has been studied.
Additional dissolution process takes place under ultrasonication, as is observed in
the anodizing curves (current density vs time) that show values on the order of ca.
200 A/m
2
. After only 30 min of ultrasound-assisted anodization at 42 V, the
resulting nanotubes length is ca. 4 μm and, in contrast, in the case of non
ultrasound-assisted anodization, the length is only ca. 1 μm. Further prolonged
anodization under ultrasound induced the complete dissolution of the titanium.
After anodization at 60 V during 20 h (no ultrasounds), the observed length of the
nanotubes is as long as ca. 45 μm. The nanotube TiO
2
aspect ratio has been
tailored between 40 and 320. The obtained nanotubes of TiO
2
exhibit high areal
capacity (up to ca. 2 mAh/cm
2
and stabilized around 0.3 to 0.5 mAh/cm
2
) and good cycling behavior in lithium batteries. A
nonlinear relationship between the nanotubes length and the resulting capacity has been revealed.
■
INTRODUCTION
The abundant reserves and low toxicity of titanium are some of
the features that let us to look at titanium oxide as a very
attractive electrode material for lithium ion batteries. In
addition, the higher intercalation voltage of titanium oxides
may render safer batteries in comparison with graphite
electrode. Unfortunately, titanium oxide usually has low
electrical conductivity and slow Li
+
insertion-extraction kinetics.
In order to overcome this problem TiO
2
can be nanostructured
to achieve shorter solid state path lengths for both Li-ion and
electron transport,
1-7
however, poor electronic conduction
network due to aggregation of nanopowders and loss of
interparticle connection during electrochemical cycling can be
suffered. In a try to improve the electrochemical behavior,
titania nanotubes can be grown by anodization of Ti foil under
the optima experimental conditions and the resulting areal
capacity values are usually below 0.1 mAh/cm
2
.
3,6,7
Batteries based on 3D micro or nanostructures can offer
advantages, such as small areal footprint, in comparison with
2D structures such as thin films.
8
To achieve a high-energy
density and a small areal footprint requires the use of 3D
batteries.
9
These batteries may improve the power-density of
the usual batteries and reduce the recharging time as is claimed
for further developing electric vehicles. Therefore, a 3D
electrode with an anatase TiO
2
layer covering aluminum
nanorods showed areal capacity values of ∼0.01 mAh/cm
2
,
which is one order of magnitude higher than that for the
equivalent 2D geometry.
9
Having all of these features in mind,
we have considered that making the TiO
2
nanotubes longer
may yield a higher capacity and power density while retaining
the same areal footprint. To study this hypothesis, we first
explored the preparation method by modification of several
experimental parameters, characterized the physical-chemical
properties of the resulting nanotubes, and finally studied the
electrochemical behavior in lithium cells.
Sonochemistry uses the application of high-intensity ultra-
sound and the so-called acoustic cavitation effect in chemical
reactions. Zhang et al. reported that the ultrasound-assisted
anodization of aluminum enhances the pores growth and
proposed that the ultrasonication can release the oxygen
bubbles (2O
=
=O
2
+ 4e
-
) from the interface, which is helpful
for the nanotubes growth.
10
The key processes responsible for
anodic formation of nanoporous alumina and TiO
2
appear to
be the same.
11-14
In this work, we have applied high-intensity ultrasonication
to the anodization of titanium to grow titania nanotubes, and
Received: May 23, 2012
Revised: September 4, 2012
Published: September 4, 2012
Article
pubs.acs.org/JPCC
© 2012 American Chemical Society 20182 dx.doi.org/10.1021/jp3050115 | J. Phys. Chem. C 2012, 116, 20182-20190