THE NEW ZEALAND
MEDICAL JOURNAL
Vol 116 No 1185 ISSN 1175 8716
NZMJ 7 November 2003, Vol 116 No 1185 Page 1 of 9
URL: http://www.nzma.org.nz/journal/116-1185/662/ © NZMA
Framingham Heart Study risk equation predicts first
cardiovascular event rates in New Zealanders at the
population level
Richard Milne, Gregory Gamble, Gary Whitlock and Rodney Jackson
Abstract
Aim To establish the population-level predictive validity of the Framingham Heart
Study risk equation used to derive cardiovascular disease risk-prediction charts for
New Zealand management guidelines on raised blood pressure and dyslipidaemia.
Methods During 1992–3, standard cardiovascular risk factors were measured in a
cohort of 6354 people (4638 men and 1716 women) aged 35–74 years with no history
of cardiovascular disease, who were either enrolled on Auckland general electoral
rolls or employed by a nationwide multi-industry corporation. Five-year
cardiovascular event rates were predicted for the cohort using a Framingham risk
equation and were compared with observed five-year cardiovascular event rates for
hospitalisation and mortality.
Results Incident cardiovascular hospitalisations or death were reported for 411 cohort
participants (325 men and 86 women) during five years of follow up. There was good
agreement between observed and predicted five-year cardiovascular event rates in all
five-year age/sex categories up to 69 years. The risk equation tended to underestimate
risk slightly in men and overestimate risk slightly in women up to 69 years, while in
70- to 74-year-olds it was accurate for men. Its accuracy in older women is uncertain.
Conclusion A Framingham Heart Study risk equation used to estimate incident
cardiovascular events in individuals without previous cardiovascular disease
accurately predicts five-year risk of hospitalisation or death from a first
cardiovascular event in New Zealand men aged 35–74 and women aged 35–69 years
at the population level.
Cardiovascular disease risk charts, based on a risk-prediction equation developed by
the Framingham Heart Study collaborators,
1
are integral to New Zealand guidelines
on the management of dyslipidaemia and raised blood pressure.
2,3
This risk equation
was designed to predict incident cardiovascular end points and was developed from
biennial medical examinations of a cohort of mainly white Americans living in the
town of Framingham, Massachusetts in the 1970s and 1980s.
1
Although the risk
charts have been used in New Zealand since 1992 and various Framingham risk
equations and associated risk scores have been validated in several populations and
ethnic groups internationally,
4,5
it is not known how well the equations predict
population risk in New Zealand.
The objective of this study was to establish the accuracy of the Framingham risk
equation at a population level, by applying the equation to a New Zealand cohort and
comparing predicted event rates with observed event rates by five-year age groups in
men and women.