1 Introduction Caribbean islands which are built on strong foundations of colonialism has been hit by societal issues such as violence and crime, gender issues such as homosexuality, heterosexuality in recent years. The issue which will be focused on in this essay will be on the topic of male marginalization and male identity crisis in the Caribbean. Being a multifocal society, the problem of male marginalization in the Caribbean has been an issue which is researched on by writers in various fields in academia, the literature on the topic suggests that Caribbean males are marginalized by Caribbean females and some writers think Caribbean males marginalize themselves, this is because analysis of the issue and social statistics and figures are not ample evidence in the marginalization discourse. The aim of this essay is to offer at least three academic scholars on the issue of male marginalization in the Caribbean by also drawing on the theories and analyses of power inequalities put forward by at least two feminist writers. This essay will attempt to use three known scholars on the issue: Barry Chavannes, Errol Miller, and Eudine Barriteau. I will offer Keisha Lindsay’s counter argument against the thesis, which is maintained that Caribbean male’s identity is in crisis, and she seeks to disproof the assumptions that Caribbean males are marginalized; this will be a feminist response to the issue. Nevertheless, I will also attempt to offer my own solution to the problem of male marginalization facing Caribbean males today.