Transformer Fault Diagnosis using Frequency
Response Analysis - Practical Studies
Hormatollah Firoozi, Mohammad Kharezi,
High voltage laboratory, Iran Transfo Co. High votage laboratory, Iran Transfo Co.
Zanjan, Iran. Zanjan, Iran
Hossein Rahimpour Mehdi Shams
Technical design Dept. of Iran-Transfo Co. Tozih Iran-Transfo Zangan Co.
Zanjan,Iran Zanjan,Iran
Abstract— Any failures in these equipments directly reduce
network reliability and increase maintenance costs.
Consequently, the preventive maintenance techniques are
increasingly developed. In this regard, frequency response
analysis is an appropriate method in order to diagnose any
change which occurs in transformer physical construction.
This contribution has been concentrated on fault diagnosis by
use of Frequency Response Analysis (FRA). A number of
measurements on faulty transformers which are led to fault
diagnosis has represented and discussed. These practical studies
are performed during maintenance processes or on site periodic
inspections. The results are very worthwhile to better understand
how behave transformer frequency responses due to various
faults. These obtained results can be very interesting and usable
for maintenance engineers to find the occurred fault.
Keywords-Frequency Response Analysis;Fault diagnosis
I. INTRODUCTION
Power transformers are one of the essential and also
expensive equipments of electrical networks which play
mainly role in the energy transmission and distribution. For
this reason, the reliability, quality and economic cost of the
company depends strongly of the transformer health and,
therefore, an intensive maintenance of the electric machine is
required. Today, preventive maintenance techniques such as
Dissolved Gas Analysis, Thermal Monitoring, Partial
Discharge measurements and Frequency Response Analysis
(FRA) have been developed [1,3]. The FRA is a powerful
method in detecting transformer mechanical damages, which
are difficult to detect by conventional measurements. It relies
on the fact that transformer winding can be modeled as a
network of capacitances, resistances and inductances. When a
failure occurs in the transformer construction, the values of
these parameters are altered and hence the frequency response
from the winding will also change accordingly.
FRA is a simple and low cost method. Also, with this
method, it might be able to recognize the type and location of
fault, which is not possible with most other methods,
involving terminal measurements. In spite of all its
advantages, frequency response technique has still not become
popular due to some limitations. These limitations can be
divided into two branches. The first one is obtaining a
repeatable frequency response through practical measurements
techniques and the second one is a lack of availability of
correlation between the signature and the changes in the
parameter of the equipment. In other words, the success of this
method relies on the correct interpretation of the accurate and
reliable measurements [4,5].
According to above discussion, it is no so easy to have a
physical interpretation of frequency response variations. For
this reason, experimental and practical studies are very
worthwhile to better understand how behave transformer
frequency responses due to various faults.
This paper represents the results of FRA measurement on
faulty transformers. These tests had been performed before
applying any other diagnostic techniques. In fact, the main
goal was the evaluation of FRA ability to recognize the
occurred fault before re-assembling of transformer. The
obtained results can be very interesting and usable for
maintenance engineers to find the occurred fault.
II. FRA MEASUREMENT METHOD
In this research work, all the frequency response
characteristics were obtained using the sweep frequency
method (SFM). Fig. 1 shows a schematic diagram of the
experimental set-up based on “FRAnalyzer” which
manufactured by OMICRON company. The injected signal S
at different frequencies is applied to one end of the test
winding and the voltage signals at both ends of the winding
are measured by the two cables called reference R and test T.
These two voltages then used to calculate the voltage ratio.
The results are presented in the form of frequency and
amplitude on a logarithmic scale as below.
) (
) (
) (
ω
ω
ω
R
T
H =
978-1-4244-6255-1/11/$26.00 ©2011 IEEE