Research Open Access
Muslims and depression: the role of religious beliefs in therapy
Shaista Meer
*
and Ghazala Mir
Abstract
Background: Policy and practice guidelines in the UK and elsewhere promote the use of culturally appropriate treatment for
clients from minority groups. he literature demonstrates religious coping can be efective in reducing levels of depression and that
people from Muslim backgrounds are likely to use religious coping techniques.
Methods: his study explored t he possibility of adapting an existing therapy to meet the needs of Muslims with depression.
Behavioural Activation (BA) was selected as an appropriate approach based on its focus on behaviour linked to values. To
investigate which adaptations were needed, interviews were carried out with practitioners (n=26) and Muslim service users (n=4).
Data was organised into themes adapted from a previous cultural adaptation of BA. hree advisory groups were consulted on t he
content of the thematic framework.
Results: he indings supported the incorporation of religious teachings within psychological therapies and highlighted the
importance of therapists creating space to discuss religion with clients who wish to. herapists recognised religion could be a useful
resource, however, oten felt ill equipped to engage with a religious framework within therapy.
Conclusions: Practitioners, including those from Muslim backgrounds, require training and guidance regarding attention to
religious beliefs within therapy. Practitioners need to be prepared to develop their knowledge of religious beliefs and cultural issues
that may arise for clients from the communities with which they work.
Keywords: Depression, islam, religion, therapy, psychology, adaptation psychological
© 2014 Meer et al; licensee Herbert Publications Ltd. his is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of Creative Commons Attribution License
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0). his permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Introduction
Muslims make up the second largest religious group in Britain
[1]. A census of UK inpatients and out patients in National Health
Service (NHS) and independent mental health services showed
that 4% of the 31,786 people recorded identified themselves
as Muslim [2]. The National Institute for Clinical Excellence
[3] and the Department of Health [4,5] promote the use of
culturally appropriate treatment for clients from minority ethnic
and faith groups. Van Loon et al., [6] have argued that higher
rates of depression in ethnic minority groups means there is
a need for culturally adapted interventions; and having an
intervention that focuses on values and beliefs specific to the
cultural group makes treatment more effective. Fernando [7]
has commented that mental health practitioners are not free
from biases or making value judgements on the individuals
they are treating; having a better understanding of the culture
or values of patients may lead to better service provision with
regards to working with cultural diversity. However, little
evidence about how to adapt therapeutic interventions for
minority religious groups is available from reviews of clinical
trials and interventions [8].
Religion and wellbeing
The concept of wellbeing has been linked to mental health in
terms of ‘the absence of mental disorder and the presence of
positive psychological resources’; [9] and the need for therapy
to influence an individual’s wellbeing through an increase in
postive emotions which in turn may improve their physical
state (which may have been effected by their depressed emo-
tional state) [10].
There is a significant body of literature indicating that religion
may influence wellbeing through pathways that are behavioural,
psychological, social and physiological; [11] and in the wider
literature, there is evidence that interventions that include faith
are effective in the treatment of depression. Religious coping
in response to stress can be both positive and negative in style.
‘Positive religious coping’ has been associated with reduced
levels of depression and the use of an internalised spiritual
belief system, providing strategies that promote hope and
resilience [12]. Religious beliefs and practices that encourage
a proactive approach to dealing with problems, are more
likely to help people overcome depression [12b]. Conversely,
aspects of religion that are negative or unhelpful, for example
perceiving illness as being abandoned or punished by God, are
defined as ‘negative religious coping’, and have been found to
increase depression and anxiety [12,13]. Ventis [14] found that
those who follow an intrinsic form of religiosity tend to report
being free from anxieties and guilt.
*
Correspondence: s.m.meer@leeds.ac.uk
Academic Unit of Psychiatry and Behavioural Sciences, Leeds Institute of Health Sciences, University of Leeds, United Kingdom.
Journal of
Integrative Psychology and herapeutics
ISSN 2054-4723
CrossMark
← Click for updates