Sociology
1–17
© The Author(s) 2014
Reprints and permissions:
sagepub.co.uk/journalsPermissions.nav
DOI: 10.1177/0038038513518850
soc.sagepub.com
Talking Like a Generation:
The ‘Documentary’ Meaning
of Ethnicity for Aging Minority
Britons
Jennifer Elrick
University of Toronto, Canada
Erik Schneiderhan
University of Toronto, Canada
Shamus Khan
Columbia University, USA
Abstract
This article contributes to the ‘cognitive turn’ in the study of ethnicity and national identity, which
focuses on how individuals construct ethnic identity categories pertinent to social cohesion.
Using Mannheim as a methodological and analytical guide, we show how examining ethnicity as a
relational enactment devoid of a priori categorisations allows situational identities that intersect
with classical sociological concepts other than ethnicity – namely generation, class, and citizenship –
to emerge within and across typical ethnic categorisations. We draw on an analysis of micro-
level interactions among 40 aging ‘Black and minority ethnics’ (BMEs) engaging in small-group
discussions and a large deliberative assembly held in London in 2011.
Keywords
citizenship, class, deliberation, documentary meaning, enactment, ethnicity, generation,
immigration, national identity, United Kingdom
There is a long-standing concern about the feasibility of social cohesion in multicultural
Britain, particularly around tendencies towards inclusion and exclusion associated with
various ethnic, religious, and national identities (Demireva, 2011). Part of understanding
Corresponding author:
Jennifer Elrick, Department of Sociology, University of Toronto, 725 Spadina Ave, Toronto, Ontario, M5S
2J4, Canada.
Email: jennifer.elrick@mail.utoronto.ca
518850SOC 0 0 10.1177/0038038513518850SociologyElrick et al.
research-article 2014
Article