Healthcare reform information-
seeking: Relationships with
uncertainty, uncertainty
discrepancy, and health
self-efficacy
Correspondence to:
Jennifer L Bevan,
One University Drive,
Chapman University,
Orange, CA 92866, USA
bevan@chapman.edu
Nasim Mirkiani Thompson, Jennifer L Bevan, Lisa Sparks
Chapman University/University of California, Irvine, CA, USA
Abstract
This exploratory study examines information-
seeking about the 2010 Patient Protection and
Affordable Care Act (i.e. healthcare reform) in
relation to the potential barriers of uncertainty,
uncertainty discrepancy, and low health self-effi-
cacy. Adult United States participants completed
an anonymous online survey about their percep-
tions and understanding of healthcare reform.
Results confirmed recent literature, suggesting a
complex relationship between information-seeking
and uncertainty. Specifically, for this sample, signifi-
cant positive relationships were observed between
information-seeking about healthcare reform and
uncertainty, uncertainty discrepancy, health self-
efficacy. Further, uncertainty discrepancy was the
potential barrier that accounted for the most var-
iance in predicting information-seeking.
Implications of these findings for improving public
understanding of healthcare reform are discussed.
Keywords: Healthcare reform, Uncertainty,
Information seeking behavior, Human information
processing, Self efficacy
On 23 March 2010, the Patient Protection and
Affordable Care Act was signed into law. During
the months leading up to and after the passage of
this legislation (hereafter called healthcare reform),
the American public was asked to consume,
process, and evaluate a large amount of complex
health-policy information. Healthcare reform is
uniquely deserving of study from a perspective
grounded in health communication research for
three reasons. First, it will directly and concurrently
impact both those who are ill and those who are
well. Second, based on one’s current health status,
healthcare reform information can include aspects
of prevention, intervention, and/or treatment.
Finally, the legislation’s partisan nature means that
individual perceptions and understandings of it
could be significantly affected by the often deep
and divisive opinions of the political entities that
oppose or support healthcare reform.
Health information can be positive or negative
1,2
and information about healthcare reform certainly
amplifies both in an effort to influence public
opinion. Indeed, a 2010 Associated Press poll
found that participants were often incorrect about
what is and is not included in the healthcare
reform bill as well as fairly uncertain about those
judgments.
3
The complexities of accessing and
understanding information certainly could be
related to the multiple potential barriers that the
public was experiencing about healthcare reform.
As such, the present study explores the role of
three variables that are consistently related to one
another in health contexts and theoretical models
in the context of public information-seeking about
healthcare reform: uncertainty, uncertainty discre-
pancy, and health self-efficacy.
Information-seeking
Information is ‘stimuli from a person’s environment
that contribute to his or her knowledge or beliefs’
4
(p. 259). Similar to the majority of information-
seeking research, the act of information-seeking
about the topic of healthcare reform is viewed here
as ‘the purposive gathering of information’
5
(p. 50). From this perspective, information-seeking
is intentional, directed by goals, and involves
behaviors such as asking questions and formally
searching databases such as the Internet.
5
As health-
care reform is a topic that was extensively covered
56
© W.S. Maney & Son Ltd 2012
DOI: 10.1179/1753807611Y.0000000016 Journal of Communication in Healthcare 2012 VOL. 5 NO. 1