Abstract
Irish–Scottish connections in the first millennium AD:
an evaluation of the links between souterrain ware
and Hebridean ceramics
IAN ARMIT
Division of Archaeological, Geographical and Environmental Sciences,
University of Bradford, United Kingdom
[Accepted 30 May 2007. Published 9 May 2008.]
Although some limited consideration has been given to the possibility of links
between the early medieval ceramic traditions of the Western Isles and the souterrain
ware of north-east Ireland, these have tended to be framed in the context of sup-
posed Dalriadic cultural influence flowing from Ireland to Scotland. A re-evaluation
of the possible relationships between these pottery styles suggests that souterrain
ware might instead be seen as part of a regional expansion of western Scottish pot-
tery styles in the seventh–eighth centuries AD. This raises the question of what social
processes might underlie the cross-regional patterning evident in what remains a
vernacular, rather than a high-status, technology.
Archaeological studies of cultural connections between Scotland and Ireland dur-
ing the first millennium AD have been hampered by a number of perceptual and
organisational factors. Modern political boundaries have inevitably led to the
emergence of distinct archaeological traditions within Scotland and Ireland, while
histories of prospection, methodologies of recording, conventions in publication,
and priorities for excavation have also evolved differently. Curatorial and clas-
sificatory systems have similarly grown up quite separately on either side of the
North Channel. While understandable for a variety of reasons, this has tended to
compartmentalise primary archaeological research and prevent the perception of
some interesting aspects of cultural patterning which cut across modern political
boundaries.
The few attempts to embrace material on both sides of the water in our period
have tended to be driven not by archaeological, but by historical or pseudo-historical
questions deriving from what are generally very partial documentary sources. For the
first millennium AD the two great marker points are of course the supposed Dalriadic
migration from Ulster to Argyll around AD 500, and the Viking movements south
and westwards through the Hebrides to south-west Scotland and Ireland from around
AD 800. It is the first of these that is of concern to us most directly here. For present
purposes, the discussion will be restricted to the specifically archaeological aspects
of the debates surrounding Scottish Dál Riata.
Proceedings of the Royal Irish Academy Vol. 108C, 1–18 © 2008 Royal Irish Academy
Introduction