341
15 Grades, gradients, and geography:
a dental morphometric approach to
the population history of South Asia
Brian E. Hemphill
Anthropological Perspectives on Tooth Morphology: Genetics, Evolution, Variation, eds.
G. Richard Scott and Joel D. Irish. Published by Cambridge University Press. © Cambridge
University Press 2013.
15.1 Introduction
The purposes of this chapter are threefold. First, it will be demonstrated that
dental observations from archaeologically derived and modern samples can
be combined without introducing systemic bias that compromises attempts to
reconstruct population history. Second, it is shown that dental morphological
trait frequencies yield similar, but distinct patterns of intersample phenetic
afinities compared to those obtained with dental metrics. Third, it will be tested
whether South Asians evidence long-standing local continuity, or whether they,
and Pakistanis in particular, experienced signiicant gene low from outside
populations.
15.1.1 Relative proportionality, tooth size gradients, allocation of
permanent tooth size
In recent years, largely as a consequence of the inluential work of Christy
Turner II, researchers interested in understanding patterns of human microevo-
lution in the post-Pleistocene era have focused their attention on the assessment
of variation in dental morphological trait frequencies. Odontometric data have
been used far less commonly for the same purpose (T. Hanihara 2008; Harris
1998; Harris and Harris 2007; Harris and Rathbun 1989, 1991; Hemphill 1991,
2008, 2009b; Hemphill et al. 1992, in press).
Multivariate studies consistently demonstrate that isometric scaling accounts
for a large proportion of the size variation across populations (Harris 1998;
9781107011458c15_p341-387.indd 341 9781107011458c15_p341-387.indd 341 10/30/2012 5:07:15 PM 10/30/2012 5:07:15 PM