Introduction to Special Issue: Figuring the Transforming City
1
JOSHUA BARKER
University of Toronto
ERIK HARMS
Yale University
JOHAN LINDQUIST
Stockholm University
I
magine, for a moment, Alfred Eisenstaedt’s famous photograph “V-J
Day in Times Square.” Two figures—a sailor and a nurse—kiss against
the background of Times Square in New York City. The background is
teeming with people. The avenues of the city, with their recognizable
billboards and marquees and telltale North-American architecture,
converge into the horizon, transforming that famous intersection into
a ground against which the kissing figures stand out. “The kiss” (as this
photograph is sometimes also known) means something more than other
kisses because it has been set against that particular background, where
sailors and civilians, many of them smiling broadly, intermingle after a
long time of war.
There are of course many photographs of lovers kissing, but this one
has achieved the status of an “iconic image.”
2
Why? It has become iconic
because it manages to convey a message about a particular feeling and
sentiment made possible by the social experience of a place called New
York City in a particular time and place. One reason it can do this is
because we know it was taken on V-J Day in the heart of a city which is
located in a nation that has just declared victory over Japan, a country
with which it has been at war. The photograph also means something
because viewers know that the city in the photograph is a place populated
by people not all that different from those in the photograph—all with
different roles to play and with different social meanings attached to
who they are and what they do. The sailor. The nurse. These are not just
individuals, but symbols of something larger than life. They have become
figures. They have come to stand for something bigger than themselves.
Yet they are real people too. When the couple was identified last
year,
3
it turned out that the woman in the photo, Gretta Zimmer
Friedman, was not expecting the kiss. “I did not see him approaching,
and before I knew it, I was in this vice grip” (Miller 2012). As one blogger
pointed out, this statement suggests that the iconic kiss—so often cel-
ebrated as a moment of 20th century American romance—might better
be understood as an example of sexual assault (Leopard 2012). In other
words, an attention to the figures as real people throws into relief a
different background: the deep-rooted sexism of early-20th century
American public culture, here expressed at a moment of masculine mili-
tary triumphalism.
City & Society, Vol. 25, Issue 2, pp. 159–172, ISSN 0893-0465, eISSN 1548-744X. © 2013 by the American
Anthropological Association. All rights reserved. DOI:10.1111/ciso.12014.