Proc. of the IEEE International Conference on Smart Instrumentation, Measurement and Applications (ICSIMA)
26-27 November 2013, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
978-1-4799-0843-1/13/$31.00 ©2013 IEEE
Flatbed Scanner Image and Single Ultrasonic
Rangefinder Technique for Composite Laminates
Defect Detection
M. F. Mahmod
1
, M. Z. Mohamed Pauzi
2
, Elmi Abu Bakar
3
School of Mechanical Engineering, Universiti Sains Malaysia
14300 Nibong Tebal, Pulau Pinang, Malaysia
1
mfaisal@uthm.edu.my
*
School of Aerospace Engineering, Universiti Sains Malaysia
14300 Nibong Tebal, Pulau Pinang, Malaysia
2
muhdzaim90@gmail.com
3
meelmi@eng.usm.my
Abstract —Inspection of composite laminates in production
line using Ultrasonic C-scan for NDT requires a competent and
experience inspector in order to analyze the signal which involve
various technical instruction. In this paper, two approaches had
been used which are image based approach and signal based
approach of ultrasonic C-Scan method for NDT of composite
laminate are developed and applied, with the aim to compare and
validate both techniques instead of surface defect percentage
area. The idea is, to propose an image analysis technique which
easy to handle by general worker either the defect percentage
area between the image and signal analysis are acceptable range
or not. Composite laminates 6 plies which produced in-house
with geometry 280 mm length x 80 mm width x 2 mm thickness
was drilled to consider as defect area. Then, further analysis was
performed using image scanning and processing to calculate the
percentage of the defect area before we proceeds to the ultrasonic
signal based approach. This research had been successfully done
with the maximum and the minimum yield percentage between
image processing and ultrasonic signal based approach method
are 17.12 percent and 8.52 percent.
Keywords— Image Based Approach, Ultrasonic Signal based
approach, Composite Laminates, Defect Detection.
I. INTRODUCTION
Composite material has been used in a wide variety of
engineering applications including aerospace, automobile,
marine and rail industries due to its high performance such as
low weight, high strength and stiffness[1]. Ye, Lu et al. [2]
mention that the composite material is being use to produce
aircraft components such as aileron, elevator, rudder control
surface, landing gear door, fuselage side panel etc. This
situation shows that the uses of composite material is being
gradually increased in aerospace manufacturing industries.
On top of that, Non Destructive Testing (NDT)
becomes a crucial process in aerospace composite
manufacturing industries where this inspection process
typically closes with a high technology detection system where
accuracy and quality of inspection is a top priority. The most
significant defects occur during the manufacturing process are
porous, and impact damage occurs during in service use
caused serious damage to composites such as delamination,
matrix and fibre cracking[1]. This entire defect will lead to
final fracture of the material. Therefore, appropriate technique
has been introduced since basic visual inspection known as
“coin tap” test [3] until Non-Destructive Test technique such as
ultrasonic, acoustic emission, thermography, laser Ultrasonics,
X-radiography, eddy currents, shearography and low frequency
methods [4].
According to Theodoros [5], ultrasonic inspection is
considered as the most efficient method used for quality
control and materials quality inspection to all major industries
including aircraft industries. However, ultrasonic inspection
technique is relatively slow in process compared to the image
processing method especially in application of the large part
products. In addition, this process requires competent and
skilful worker due to its complicated signal analysis and setup,
while image based approach which is using slightly automated
process control might be conduct by a general worker with less
of inspection knowledge.
In this research, the results of percentage defects
between image based approach which used flatbed scanner
image and ultrasonic signal based approach which used single
ultrasonic range finder technique are being compared and
discussed in order to obtain the best solution. According to
Ukida and colleagues [6], instead of the image scanner process,
image based approach is an important technique for the object
digital archiving, shape analysing, referencing over the network
and so on. Moreover, this technique consumes less operation
time compare to single ultrasonic range finder. Therefore, this
technique is recommended over the single ultrasonic range
finder technique especially for surface defect detection system.
Furthermore, it requires less technical instruction during
operation for general worker. Besides that, it also can be able to
operate via online networking system where the inspection
results become more reliable and also the number of inspection
operator may reduce for cost effective purpose.