Practices of Stigmergy in the Building Process
Lars Rune Christensen
Aalborg University Copenhagen, Department of Learning and Philosophy, Techno-antropology Research
Group, A. C. Meyers Vænge 15, DK-2450 Copenhagen S, Denmark (E-mail: Lrc@learning.aau.dk)
Abstract. Actors coordinate their cooperative efforts by acting on the evidence of work
previously accomplished. Based on a field study this article introduces the concept of stigmergy
to the analysis of coordinative practices in the building process. It distinguishes between practices
of stigmergy, articulation work and awareness practices. Stigmergy is understood as coordination
achieved by acting directly on the evidence of work previously accomplished by others. The article
provides descriptions of stigmergy in the building process i.e. in design as well as construction
work. It seeks to (1) introduce the concept of stigmergy to CSCW, (2) to delimit this concept in
regard to other concepts of coordination such as articulation work and awareness and (3) to provide
descriptions of practices of stigmergy in the building process and, in this capacity, to help explain
how complex large-scale cooperative work is coordinated.
Key words: coordination, building process, stigmergy, articulation work, awareness
1. Introduction
1
Designing and constructing a large building is a highly complex cooperative
work endeavour constituted by numerous distributed and interdependent tasks
carried out by a diverse network of actors over a period of several years. For each
unique major building project a network of actors is created or configured. The
network is a diverse ensemble drawn from many different professions, working
for many different companies. Some are with the project from start to finish, for
instance the client and the main architects, while others such as the general
contractor and the various subcontractors, including building engineers, concrete
specialists, carpenters, plumbers, electricians, painters, roofing specialists,
ventilation specialists etc. are associated with the project only for the duration
of their allotted tasks. Specifically, the network of actors are involved in
interdependent tasks pertaining to design and construction such as ensuring that
the design of the concrete structure of the building is aligned with the design of
the building services
2
or, in the construction phase, that the construction of the
steel skeleton of walls is aligned with the wiring of electricity—one large
1
This article draws on findings and analyses presented in articles published over the last couple of years
(i.e. Christensen 2007; Christensen 2008). Furthermore, it overlaps somewhat with findings presented in
Christensen (2013).
2
Building services include e.g. electricity, ventilation, sanitation, heating and cooling and etc.
Computer Supported Cooperative Work (2014) 23:1–19 © Springer Science+Business
DOI 10.1007/s10606-012-9181-3 Media Dordrecht 2012