Biology and Philosophy 18: 249–284, 2003.
© 2003 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
Plants and the Conceptual Articulation of
Evolutionary Developmental Biology
FRANCISCO VERGARA-SILVA
*
Laboratorio de Genética Molecular y Evolución
Departamento de Ecología Evolutiva
Instituto de Ecología
UNAM; México D.F. 04510
México
1. Introduction
A considerable number of biologists and a growing number of philosophers
of biology are currently participating in an enthusiastic discussion of the role
of developmental processes in the determination of evolutionary pattern and
the phenotypic aspects of biodiversity. The main themes of this discussion
are not original,
1
but most people concerned with the history of evolutionary
biology – for professional reasons or otherwise – acknowledge that their
current, renewed relevance is inevitable. On one hand, the existence of the
molecular biology techniques that have led to the results that nowadays form
the experimental core of studies in evolutionary developmental biology
2
was
not even imagined when the questions first arose; on the other, an appro-
priate conceptual integration between ontogeny and evolution was never
fulfilled within the paradigmatic theory in the field, the Modern Synthesis
(see, for example, Gilbert et al. 1996; Amundson 1998, 2001). Arguably,
disagreements with the latter claim
3
and associated issues related to models of
epistemological change in evolutionary biology will continue to be the main
focus for philosophers and historians, regardless of the taxonomic affinity of
the organisms from which the developmental-genetic data are collected (see,
for instance, Robert 2001; Griffiths 2002; Love, this issue). However, since
the concepts and experimental facts that give evo-devo its individuality as a
scientific discourse come from the study of developmental mechanisms, it is
*
Current address: Department of Physiological Botany, Evolutionary Biology Centre,
Uppsala University, Uppsala 75236, Sweden.