Voices of care for adults with disabilities and/or mental health issues in
Western Canada: what do families and agencies need from each other?
Laura R. Mooney MSc and Bonnie Lashewicz PhD
Community Health Sciences, Faculty of Medicine, University of Calgary, Calgary, Alberta, Canada
Accepted for publication 8 August 2013
Correspondence
Bonnie Lashewicz
Community Health Sciences,
Faculty of Medicine
University of Calgary
Room 3D20, TRW Building, 3280
Hospital Drive NW
Calgary, Alberta, Canada T2N 4Z6
E-mail: bmlashew@ucalgary.ca
What is known about this topic
•
Collaboration between formal, paid
caregivers and informal, family
caregivers is central to well-
supported futures for adults with
pre-existing disabilities and/or
mental health issues.
•
Families often view paid caregivers
and agencies as inadequately
responsive to their desire for
involvement.
•
Paid caregivers struggle with
families who are demanding and
others who are uninvolved and
hard to reach.
What this paper adds
•
Relationships between families and
paid supports can be complex,
Abstract
Our purpose in this paper is to report on the frustrations and unmet
needs of paid, formal caregivers and unpaid, family caregivers who
together provide care to adults with disabilities and/or mental health
issues. We conducted eight focus group interviews between November
2010 and June 2011 in two large, urban centres and one smaller centre in
Western Canada. Four of our focus groups were with family members
including adults with disabilities and/or mental health issues, their
parents and their siblings, and four were with representatives from
agencies providing support and services to adults with disabilities
and/or mental health issues and their families. Data were collected from
23 family members and 24 agency representatives who responded to
questions about successes and struggles in meeting, and collaborating to
meet, care needs of adults with disabilities and/or mental health issues.
Each focus group session was digitally recorded and transcribed; field
notes were also taken and we thematically analysed data according to
family versus agency perspectives of their successes and barriers in care
provision and care collaboration. We found that family members desire
greater and more effective support in enriching the lives of adults with
disabilities and/or mental health issues and in preparing for age-related
changes. Agency representatives are keenly aware of the needs and
challenges faced by families, yet grapple with being effective
collaborators with families of widely varying priorities and styles of care
and collaboration.
Keywords: adult mental healthcare, collaborative practice, disabilities, family
caregivers, family support, paid caregivers
uneven and sometimes
characterised by conflict.
•
Families often do not plan for age-
related change and collaboration
with agencies is vital to
anticipating and effectively
navigating next steps in care for
adults with disabilities and/or
mental health issues.
•
Agencies face many, and often
competing, demands in
endeavours to support families
who have diverse priorities and
styles of care and collaboration.
Introduction
Adults with pre-existing disabilities and/or mental health issues are liv-
ing longer than ever before, bringing new demands for planning and pro-
viding for futures that extend beyond the care capacity of their ageing
parents. Effective collaboration between formal, paid caregivers and infor-
mal, family caregivers is central to well-supported futures for people as
they grow older with pre-existing disabilities and/or mental health
issues. Much has been written about the contributions of, and demands
on, these parties in their respective endeavours, and practice guidelines
have been developed to promote effective collaboration between the two.
Yet, both parties continue to experience frustrations and unaddressed
needs in relation to their collaboration. Existing literature on obstacles to
collaboration between paid and family caregivers tends to be focused on
family perceptions of paid caregivers as inadequately responsive to
© 2013 John Wiley & Sons Ltd 178
Health and Social Care in the Community (2014) 22(2), 178–186 doi: 10.1111/hsc.12074