Robust Stability and Disturbance Attenuation Analysis of a Class of Networked Control Systems
Hai Lin
Department of Electrical Engineering
University of Notre Dame
Notre Dame, IN 46556, USA
Guisheng Zhai
Department of Opto-Mechartronics
Wakayama University
Sakaedani, Wakayama 640-8510, Japan
Panos J. Antsaklis
Department of Electrical Engineering
University of Notre Dame
Notre Dame, IN 46556, USA
Abstract— In this paper, stability and disturbance attenua-
tion issues for a class of Networked Control Systems (NCSs)
under uncertain access delay and packet dropout effects are
considered. Our aim is to find conditions on the delay and
packet dropout rate, under which the system stability and
H
∞
disturbance attenuation properties are preserved to a
desired level. The basic idea in this paper is to formulate such
Networked Control System as a discrete-time switched system.
Then the NCSs’ stability and performance problems can be
reduced to corresponding problems for the switched systems,
which have been studied for decades and for which a number
of results are available in the literature. The techniques in this
paper are based on recent progress in the discrete-time switched
systems and piecewise Lyapunov functions.
I. INTRODUCTION
By Networked Control Systems (NCSs), we mean feed-
back control systems where networks, typically digital band-
limited serial communication channels, are used for the
connections between spatially distributed system components
like sensors and actuators to controllers. These channels may
be shared by other feedback control loops. In traditional feed-
back control systems these connections are through point-to-
point cables. Compared with the point-to-point cables, the
introduction of serial communication networks has many
advantages, such as high system testability and resource
utilization, as well as low weight, space, power and wiring
requirements [9], [14]. These advantages make the networks
connecting sensors/actuators to controllers more and more
popular in many applications, including traffic control, satel-
lite clusters, mobile robotics etc. Recently modeling, analysis
and control of networked control systems with limited com-
munication capability has emerged as a topic of significant
interest to control community, see for example [4], [3], [6],
[14], [1], [9].
Time delay typically has negative effects on the Networked
Control Systems’ stability and performance. There are sev-
eral situations where time delay may arise. First, transmission
delay is caused by the limited bit rate of the communication
channels. Secondly, the channel in NCSs is usually shared
by multiple sources of data, and the channel is usually
multiplexed by time-division method. Therefore, there are
delays caused by a node waiting to send out a message
through a busy channel, which is usually called accessing
delay and serves as the main source of delays in NCSs. There
are also some delays caused by processing and propagation,
which are usually negligible for NCSs. Another interesting
problem in NCSs is the packet dropout issue. Because of
the uncertainties and noise in the communication channels,
there may exist unavoidable errors in the transmitted packet
or even loss
1
. If this happens, the corrupted packet is dropped
and the receiver (controller or actuator) uses the packet
that it received most recently. In addition, packet dropout
may occur when one packet, say sampled values from the
sensor, reaches the destination later than its successors. In
such situation, the old packet is dropped, and its successive
packet is used instead. There is another important issue in
NCSs, that is the quantization effect. With finite bit-rate
constraints, quantization has to be taken into consideration
in NCSs. Therefore, quantization and limited bit rate issues
have attracted many researchers’ attention, see for example
[3], [6], [4]. It has been known [3], [6] that an exponential
data representation scheme is most desirable under certain
conditions.
In this paper, we consider uncertain time delay and packet
dropout issues of NCSs in the framework of switched sys-
tems. The strength of this approach comes from the solid
theoretic results existing in the literature for stability, robust
performance etc. for switched systems. By a switched system,
we mean a hybrid dynamical system consisting of a finite
number of subsystems described by differential or difference
equations and a logical rule that orchestrates switching be-
tween these subsystems. Properties of this type of model have
been studied for the past fifty years to consider engineering
systems that contain relays and/or hysteresis. Recently, there
has been increasing interest in the stability analysis and
switching control design of switched systems (see, e.g., [10],
[5], [11], [12] and the references cited therein). Notice that
hybrid/switched system research has provided useful results
and promising techniques to deal with NCSs with delay and
packet dropout effects. For example, in [14], the multiple
Lyapunov function method [2] was employed to analyze the
stability of NCSs with network-induced delay. In addition,
the packet dropout effects in NCSs are closely related to
the controller failures studied in the fault tolerance literature.
There are some recent work on the controller failure analysis
based on switched system techniques [11], [13]. By using a
piecewise Lyapunov function, the author in [13] showed that
if the controller failures did not occur too frequently or last
1
Error control coding and/or Automatic Repeat reQuest (ARQ) mecha-
nism may be employed, but the possibility of error occurring still exists.
Proceedings of the 42nd IEEE
Conference on Decision and Control
Maui, Hawaii USA, December 2003 TuP06-2
0-7803-7924-1/03/$17.00 ©2003 IEEE 1182