1
st
Int’l Conf. on Recent Advances in Information Technology | RAIT-2012 |
978-1-4577-0697-4/12/$26.00 ©2012 IEEE
BPNN and ANFIS Models for Prediction of Floor
Bearing Characteristics of Weak Rock Foundations
Sriram V. V. N. Malladi
Department of Mechanical Engineering & Mining
Machinery Engineering
Indian School of Mines, Dhanbad, INDIA-826004
malladisriram@gmail.com
Dheeraj Kumar
Department of Mining Engineering,
Indian School of Mines, Dhanbad, INDIA-826004
dheeraj@dkumar.org
Abstract: Analysis of stability (mainly bearing strength and
settlement) under a footing on regularly bedded, jointed and
layered model rock mass is conducted using Back Propagating
Neural Network (BPNN) and Adaptive Neuro Fuzzy Inference
Systems (ANFIS). The inputs required for the modeling were
imported from the laboratory results of the measurements
carried out earlier [1]. Rock mass were modeled as elastic-
plastic with Drucker- Prager failure criteria for plane strain
condition. The results of the footing settlements and bearing
strengths derived from BPNN and ANFIS models were
compared with the footing settlements corresponding to the
maximum applied bearing pressure on floor strata (for
different sizes of footing plates and also under varying
anisotropy conditions of floor strata) as obtained from the
experimental results and FEM investigations and the bearing
strengths obtained from the laboratory investigations. It is
deduced that ANFIS model predicts accurately well vis-à-vis
experimental results though the results predicted from BPNN
model compares well with those of FEM analysis.
Keywords: ANFIS, Neuro Fuzzy, ANN, Bearing strength,
Settlement
I. INTRODUCTION
There is a general tendency to assume that any structure
founded on bedrock will be totally safe against settlement
and instability. Despite the apparently favorable stability
conditions for structures founded on rock, there are
instances of foundation failure too. Failure may include
excessive settlement due to the presence of undetected weak
seams, or deterioration of the rock with time, as well as
collapse resulting from movement of block of rock in the
foundation formed by continuous intersecting joints,
bedding planes or faults. The discontinuous planes of cracks
and joints in rock mass are considered as important factors
influencing the local stabilities of rock foundations. The
majority of foundation on rock are spread footings at the
ground surface.
Several studies were carried out widely for experimental
determination and theoretical and statistical estimation of
bearing capacity [2, 3, 4, and 5] involving laborious
experimental setup and complex underlying physical
process parameters thus resulting into conservative findings.
Settlement prediction is one of the most challenging
geotechnical engineering problems because a considerable
level of uncertainty often affects it which in turn influences
design. Several researchers [6, 7, 8, and 9] have predicted
settlement using various uncertain parameters, analytical
methods, regression analysis and simplified methods.
The conventional plate loading test, punch test and other
similar tests used for determination of bearing capacity in
laboratory or field take long time and at the same time these
tests results are quite varying due to the experimental
limitations. In such situation, Artificial Intelligence is
potentially useful, where the underlying physical process
relationships are not fully understood and well-suited in
modeling dynamic systems on a real-time basis, for
predicting the floor bearing characteristics of weak rock
foundations. In recent times, ANNs have been applied to
many geotechnical engineering applications. For example,
ANNs have been used in pile bearing capacity prediction
[10]; stress-strain modeling of sands [11]. Zhou and Wu
[12] have used these networks to interpret the site
investigation. The settlements predicted using ANN tool
were compared with the values predicted by three
commonly used deterministic methods. The results
indicated that ANNs are a promising method for predicting
settlement of shallow foundations on cohesionless soils, as
they perform better than the conventional methods. Several
researchers, as mentioned above, have studied the different
aspects in geotechnical engineering by using ANN
modeling. However, the application of ANN in predicting
the floor bearing characteristics of weak rock formations is
relatively few. Thus, the present study developed a model
on predicting the settlement and bearing strength of weak
rock formations by using ANN programming.
The main objective of this research finding is concerned
with making more accurate predictions with the help of
ANN and ANFIS models in respect of bearing strength and
settlement and study how the predictions compare with the
experimental and FEM analysis of bearing characteristics of
weak floor rock foundations (massive, jointed and layered)
of limited and varying thickness. The Neural Network
toolbox and the Fuzzy Logic toolbox provided by the
MATLAB 7.6 have been used in the present work.