Environmental Values 13 (2004): 421–48
© 2004 The White Horse Press
Environmental Risks, Uncertainty and
Intergenerational Ethics
KRISTIAN SKAGEN EKELI
Department of Philosophy
NTNU – Norwegian University of Science and Technology
7491 Trondheim, Norway
Email: kristian.skagen.ekeli@hf.ntnu.no
ABSTRACT
The way our decisions and actions can affect future generations is surrounded
by uncertainty. This is evident in current discussions of environmental risks
related to global climate change, biotechnology and the use and storage of
nuclear energy. The aim of this paper is to consider more closely how uncer-
tainty affects our moral responsibility to future generations, and to what extent
moral agents can be held responsible for activities that inlict risks on future
people. It is argued that our moral responsibility to posterity is limited because
our ability to foresee how present decisions and activities will affect future
people is limited. The reason for this is primarily that we are in a situation of
ignorance regarding the pace and direction of future scientiic and technological
development. This ignorance reduces our responsibility in a temporal dimension
because in most areas it is impossible to predict the interests and resource needs
of future generations. In one area, however, we have fairly reliable knowledge
about future people. It is reasonable to assume that future human beings will
have the same basic physiological (physical and biological) needs as we have.
On this basis, it is argued that we can be held responsible for activities causing
avoidable damage to critical resources that are necessary to provide for future
physiological needs. Furthermore, it is suggested that it is prima facie immoral
to impose risks upon future generations in cases where the following condi-
tions are fulilled: (1) the risk poses a threat to the ability of future generations
to meet their physiological needs, and (2) the risk assessment is supported by
scientiically based harm scenarios.
KEYWORDS
Moral responsibility, future generations, uncertainty, environmental risks, rea-
sonable and unreasonable risks