Language Learning & Technology
http://llt.msu.edu/issues/october2012/review1.pdf
October 2012, Volume 16, Number 3
pp. 35–39
Copyright © 35
REVIEW OF DECONSTRUCTING DIGITAL NATIVES
Deconstructing Digital Natives: Young People,
Technology, and the New Literacies
Michael Thomas (Ed.)
2011
ISBN: 9780415889964
US $ 39.95 (paperback)
216 pp.
Routledge
New York, NY
Review by Mark Evan Nelson, Deakin University, Australia
Deconstructing Digital Natives is a volume much needed and a long time in coming: ten years, to be
precise. This book, edited by Michael Thomas, is an unprecedented assemblage of critical scholarly
perspectives on the digital native, a concept contraposed to the digital immigrant within Marc Prensky‘s
bipartite formulation for ―describing the differences that many people observed, around the turn of the
twenty-first century, between the attitudes of younger and older people regarding digital technology‖ (p.
15) as Prensky explains in his own contributed article to this collection. In his first published discussion
of these ideas ten years ago, a short two-part essay in 2001, Prensky identifies digital natives as ―‗native
speakers‘ of the digital language of computers, video games, and the Internet‖ and digital immigrants as
―[t]hose of us who were not born into the digital world but have, at some later point in our lives, become
fascinated by or adopted many or most aspects of the new technology‖ (Prensky, pp. 1–2). Since its
introduction a decade ago, this metaphoric distinction has penetrated seemingly every scholarly,
professional, and even political conversation on digital technologies, youth, and education; virtually
hundreds of thousands of pages of internet real estate are now dedicated to discussion of this particular
―discontinuity‖ or ―singularity‖ (Prensky, 2001, p. 1). More, this and similar conceptions—a notable
example being Tapscott‘s (1998, 2009) net generation—have incited widespread, heated debate: fervent
support of its explanatory value in understanding the peculiarities, needs, and preferences of supposedly
distinct younger cohorts of digitally networked cyber-citizens, as well as acerbic criticism of the
purportedly reductive, if not also potentially harmful segregation of youth from their elders on opposing
sides of a yawning digital generation gap, among other hotly contested positions. Deconstructing Digital
Natives presents what is arguably the most comprehensive, nuanced treatment to date of these complex,
impassioned debates.
This edited volume features an insightful foreword by David Buckingham and twelve chapters, among
whose authors are some of the most notable contributors thus far to the international scholarly
conversation on digital natives and education. The chapters are divided into three sections, titled
Reflecting on the Myth, Perspectives, and Beyond Digital Natives, respectively introducing and examining
the varied interpretations and significance of Prensky‘s ideas; reporting on research that empirically
grounds and tests the digital natives/digital immigrants formulation; and attempting to reconcile
heretofore entrenched oppositions and move the conversation in productive new directions.