Politics & Policy • Volume 34 • No. 1 • March 2006
© 2006 by the Policy Studies Organization. All rights reserved.
The War About the War: Iraq and the
Politics of National Security Advising in the
G.W. Bush Administration’s First Term
Chris J. Dolan, Ph.D.
University of Central Florida
David B. Cohen, Ph.D.
The University of Akron
The purpose of this article is to examine the extent to which the
management system and foreign policy advisory structures of the George
W. Bush Administration led the president to launch the invasion of Iraq
in March 2003. We contend that the decision to attack Iraq was an
outgrowth of the conflict that began when the administration’s national
security team was assembled after Bush’s electoral victory and was a by-
product of the president’s management style. We devote significant
attention to the internal battles surrounding the decision for war between
those who believe in a traditional multilateral approach (realists) to
world politics and those who believe in a Pax Americana built on
unilateralism (neocons). The article concludes that in addition to the
way President Bush organized the decision-making process, his
propensity for delegating responsibility to others combined with policy
making structures built largely on consensus and personality factors, as
opposed to procedures and processes, ultimately drove the White House
toward the use of military force in Iraq.
Four years after the 9/11 attacks, President George W. Bush and
his advisers have altered America’s national security orientation from
multilateralism toward unilateral preventive war, have asserted U.S.
global preeminence, and have put the world on notice that the
war against terrorism would continue for the foreseeable future. These
pillars have come to form what many describe as the Bush Doctrine
(Glad and Dolan 2004). In particular, the strategic doctrinal alteration
in American foreign policy priorities and the decision to invade Iraq
were contrived by the architects of the Bush administration’s preventive
war objectives, the sources of which pre-date the 9/11 attacks. In the
Blackwell Publishing Ltd.Oxford, UK and Malden, USAPOPLPolitics & Policy1555-56232006 Blackwell Publishing LtdMarch 2006341••••Original Articles The War About the WarPolitics & Policy