System Identification for Unmanned Marine Vehicles
using Interval Analysis
S K Das, V Kumar and D Pal
Robotics & Automation
CSIR-CMERI
Durgapur, West Bengal INDIA, PIN-713209
Email: subhrakanti.das82@gmail.com
K Banerjee and C Mazumdar
Deptt of EIE & CSE
University of Jadavpur
Kolkata, West Bengal INDIA PIN-700032
Abstract—The aim in the present paper remains to describe a
system identification method for unmanned marine vehicles using
interval analysis in order to come up with estimation of parameter
intervals instead of real values, such that the actual dynamics
of the system shall remain confined within guaranteed bounds.
The bounds are propagated through the system equations using
such interval based parameters. The proposed method exploits
guaranteed error bounds for the state variables as observed
by different sensors. Unlike conventional Kalman estimators the
adopted method rules out the requirement for determining co-
variance matrices and approximated Jacobians. Interval based
variables are used in constructing interval matrices. Principle of
Least Squares is used in solving the system equation involving
such non-punctual (interval) matrices. In this context a sophisti-
cated interval matrix inversion technique is employed within the
least squares framework in finally determining the parameter
intervals.
I. I NTRODUCTION
Unmanned Marine Vehicles are systems capable of
autonomous maneuvering and navigation targeted towards
oceanography or respective sea operations. A thorough un-
derstanding of the system’s dynamic behavior as governed by
the various modalities of the system along with several uncer-
tainties, is thus essential for successful control and guidance
of the vehicle. This is often realized by open loop system
identification, in order that the model parameters are fitted
against data collected from actual operations of the vehicle
under sophisticated configurations as for instance fixed thrust
or motion profiles etc. The parameters are initialized with
values known from some initial analysis or design. However,
the accuracy of parameter identification is largely defined by
the observations as collected during experiments with the ve-
hicle, mainly accelerations, linear and angular velocities. The
uncertainties associated with such data in the form of sensor
noise as well as external disturbances, may significantly affect
the parameters evaluated through identification. Conventional
estimators like Kalman filters have been employed in order to
estimate the parameters using system model equations, thereby
taking into consideration the measurement noise associated
with sensors. In the same line of thought the aim in the
present paper remains to describe a sensor fusion approach
using interval analysis in order to come up with parameter
intervals instead of real values, such that the actual dynamics
of the system shall remain confined within guaranteed bounds
propagated through the system equations using such interval
based parameters. The proposed method exploits guaranteed
error bounds for the state variables as observed by different
sensors. Unlike conventional Kalman estimators the adopted
method rules out the requirement for determining co-variance
matrices and approximated Jacobians. Interval based variables
are used in constructing interval matrices. Principle of Least
Squares is used in solving the system equation involving such
non-punctual (interval) matrices. In this context a sophisticated
interval matrix inversion technique is employed within the least
squares framework in finally determining the parameter inter-
vals. Conventional approaches are proved to be inapplicable for
the present case. Hansen’s interval hull technique for finding
out an inverted interval matrix is used as the basis for the
proposed approach.
The organization of the paper is as follows- section II summa-
rizes a priori art in the field of system identifications carried out
for unmanned marine vehicles. Conventional estimators like
Kalman filters are discussed in this regard. Section III describes
the problem associated with identifying model parameters.
The general dynamics of such systems are formulated and
a Least Square solution framework is established. Subse-
quently, section IV presents the methodology adopted towards
identifying parameter intervals. A discussion regarding the
problems encountered with available methods due to Krawczyk
or Nirmala and Ganesan, is presented at the outset. Following
the inconsistencies, a partitioned hull approach towards finding
interval matrix inverse is described. Finally, experimental setup
is detailed and field results are obtained. Parameter intervals
are estimated using a data set collected during a single trial.
Overestimated intervals are constricted heuristically. The con-
stricted intervals are verified with another data set. Results are
summarized accordingly.
II. PRIORI ART
A multi-layered connectionist neural network (N-N) model
is adopted in the work of Hassan et al [1]. Two phase N-N
has been designed with the first layer identifying single degrees
of freedom parameters, and the subsequent identifying couped
parameters. However, the work ignores typical stochastic errors
associated with sensors from which data are collected during
the trials. As a result, training of the neural network remains
subject to stochastic disturbances associated with correspond-
ing measurements.
Jay et al in his thesis work [2], adopted a least squares
fit to side slip and turn rate data using maximum likelihood
of batch processing, in order to estimate steering equation
parameters. The identification process requires some controller
978-1-4799-3646-5/14/$31.00 ©2014 IEEE