Lesbian couples’ management of
public-private dialectical
contradictions
Elizabeth A. Suter
University of Denver
Karla Mason Bergen
College of Saint Mary
Karen L. Daas
St. Mary’s University
Wesley T. Durham
University of Southern Indiana
ABSTRACT
This study explores the processes by which a group of lesbian
women report managing public-private dialectical contradic-
tions at the external border between their relationship as a
couple and networks, social norms, and laws. Specifically, 18
dyads and 2 individuals, all of whom had been in a committed
relationship for at least 1 year, were interviewed about the
rituals that are part of their relationship. Transcripts of the
interviews were analyzed using grounded theory. Participants
reported using the dialectic response strategies of integration
and segmentation to manage the inclusion-seclusion and
revelation-concealment dimensions of the public-private
contraction.
KEY WORDS: communication theory • couples • dialectics •
grounded theory • homosexuality • lesbianism • nonreligious
rites • social networks • social norms
Journal of Social and Personal Relationships Copyright © 2006 SAGE Publications
(www.sagepublications.com),Vol. 23(3): 349–365. DOI: 10.1177/0265407506064201
This research was partially funded by a Grant-in-Aid received by the first author from the
University of Nebraska-Lincoln Research Council. An earlier version of this article was
presented to the National Communication Association, Miami Beach, FL, November 2003. All
correspondence concerning this article should be addressed to Elizabeth A. Suter, Department
of Human Communication Studies, University of Denver, 2000 E. Asbury Ave., Denver, CO
80208, USA [e-mail: esuter@du.edu]. Valerie Manusov was the Action Editor on this article.