Thal et al. : Vocabulary and Grammar Measure for Spanish-Speaking Toddlers 1087
Donna Thal
San Diego State University
San Diego, CA
and
University of California,
San Diego
Donna Jackson-Maldonado
University of Querétaro
Querétaro, Mexico
Dora Acosta
San Diego State University
San Diego, CA
The validity of the Fundación MacArthur Inventario del Desarrollo de Habilidades
Comunicativas: Palabras y Enunciados (IDHC:PE) was examined with twenty 20-
and nineteen 28-month-old, typically developing, monolingual, Spanish-speaking
children living in Mexico. One measure of vocabulary (number of words) and two
measures of grammar (mean of the three longest utterances and grammatical
complexity score) from the IDHC:PE were compared to behavioral measures of
vocabulary (number of different words from a language sample and number of
objects named in a confrontation naming task) and one behavioral measure of
grammar (mean length of utterance from a language sample). Only vocabulary
measures were assessed in the 20-month-olds because of floor effects on the
grammar measures. Results indicated validity for assessing expressive vocabulary
in 20-month-olds and expressive vocabulary and grammar in 28-month-olds.
KEY W ORDS: parent report, language development, Spanish, vocabulary,
grammar
Validity of a Parent-Report
Measure of Vocabulary and
Grammar for Spanish-Speaking
Toddlers
Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research • Vol. 43 • 1087–1100 • October 2000 • ©American Speech-Language-Hearing Association
1092-4388/ 00/ 4305-1087
P
arent report has had an off-again on-again relationship with the
field of developmental psycholinguistics. Over the last 10 years,
with the development of new instruments (Fenson et al., 1993,
1994; Rescorla, 1989), the methodology has re-emerged and is being
widely used for both clinical and research purposes. The usefulness of
these instruments has spawned development of similar instruments in
a number of other languages, including American Sign Language (Reilly,
1992), Chinese (Tardif, Gelman, & Xu, 1999; Wu, 1997), Dutch (Lejaegere,
in process), Finnish (Lyytinen, Poikkeus, & Laakso, 1997; Lyytinen,
Poikkeus, Leiwo, Ahonen, & Lyytinen, 1996), French (Poulin-Dubois,
Graham, & Sippola, 1995), German (Grimm, Doil, Müller, & Wilde, 1996),
Hebrew (Meital, Dromi, Sagi, & Bornstein, submitted), Icelandic
(Thordardottir, 1996), Italian (Caselli & Casadio, 1995), Japanese (Ogura,
Yamashita, Murase, & Dale, 1993), Korean (Pae, 1993), Spanish
(Fernandez & Umbel, 1991; Jackson-Maldonado, Thal, Marchman, Bates,
& Gutierrez-Clellen, 1993), and Swedish (Berglund & Eriksson, 1996).
For the United States and Mexico, one of the most important new in-
ventories is the Fundación MacArthur Inventario del Desarrollo de
Habilidades Comunicativas (Jackson-Maldonado, Bates, & Thal, 1992).
In this paper we report the validity of parent report of vocabulary and
grammar for 20- and 28-month-old children using the Palabras y