2014 IEEE International Conference on Advanced Communication Control and Computing Technologies (ICACCCT)
ISBN No. 978-1-4799-3914-5/14/$31.00 ©2014 IEEE 512
Performance Evaluation of MCML-Based
XOR/XNOR Circuit at 16-nm Technology Node
Amit Krishna Dwivedi
1
, Pragya Srivastava
2
, Farha Tarannum
3
, Smriti Suman
4
, Aminul Islam
5
1,2,3,4,5
Department of Electronics and Communication Engineering, Birla Institute of Technology, Mesra,Ranchi, Jharkhand, India
1
amit10011.13@bitmesra.ac.in,
2
pragya10008.12@bitmesra.ac.in,
3
fashu.farha@gmail.com,
4
smriti1214.11@bitmesra.ac.in
Abstract—MOS current mode logic (MCML) is an emerging logic
family which is gaining attention due to its high speed of
operation, robust performance and presence of mere switching
noise as compared to the CMOS logic family. In this paper we
have explored various XOR circuits in terms of propagation
delay (t
p
), average power (PWR) and power delay product (PDP)
at 16-nm Technology node. Variability analysis establishes High
Speed 8T (HS-8T) XOR circuit as fastest and robust CMOS
based XOR circuit among the other CMOS counterparts.
Further, realization of XOR circuit is done using MCML
topology. This paper also highlights various design issues in
CMOS implementation and provides an analytical formulation of
design using MCML to overcome different tradeoffs. MCML
based XOR circuit proved to be even faster than High Speed 8T
(HS-8T) XOR circuit. In particular, MCML based XOR circuit
shows 107.384 × improvement in t
p
and 3.654 × improvement in
PDP at nominal voltage of V
DD
= 0.7 V. Variability analysis
establishes MCML based XOR circuit as the most resilient and
immune to various electrical parameters.
Keywords— average power (PWR); high speed; MOS current mode
logic (MCML); XOR/XNOR circuit; power dealy product (PDP);
propagation delay (t
p
); variability; robust.
I. INTRODUCTION
The on-chip integration of various analog and digital
circuits requires higher speed of operation with less power
consumption. The conventional CMOS technology is not
capable of providing an efficient solution to these
requirements. The emerging class of MOS current mode logic
(MCML) is proving to be a promising technology for the
current trends of technology requirements due to its higher
speed of operation. MOS implementation of current mode
logic (CML) is preferred over bipolar CML because of
scalability of its feature size and less power consumption with
higher speed of operation [1] [2] [3].
XOR circuits are an elementary building block of various
complex circuits. XOR circuit can be also used as a buffer or
inverter by making one of its input low and one of its input
high respectively. Many arithmetic logic circuits such as full
adder, computational logic comparator, parity
generator/checker for error detection circuits, and so on are
designed using an exclusive-OR as their basic functional unit.
Thus XOR circuits play a major role in determining the
overall performance of these circuits.
This paper investigates different types of XOR circuit in
terms of different design metric such as propagation delay (t
p
),
power consumption and power dissipation. The optimal XOR
circuit realized using CMOS logic is later compared with
XOR circuit implemented using MOS current mode logic
(MCML) topology. Although CMOS implementation
possesses advantage in terms of static power dissipation but
conventional CMOS cannot simultaneously satisfy
requirements of both speed and power requirements for these
circuits [4].
MCML provides high speed of operation with low supply
noise generation and high noise immunity. These properties of
MCML logic family help us to integrate analog and digital
blocks on a single chip. The implementation using MCML
logic family faces tough challenges due to its complex circuit
design. These design issues are resolved to some extends by
providing an efficient alternate design [4].
To verify the results, extensive simulations on HSPICE
using 16-nm PTM (developed by the Nano scale Integration
and Modeling (NIMO) Group at Arizona State University
(ASU) [5] are carried out at nominal V
DD
of 0.7 V.
The rest of the paper is organized as follows. Various XOR
circuits are briefly examined in terms of different design
metrics in the Section II. In Section III the XOR circuit is
realized using MOS current mode logic (MCML) topology.
Optimal circuit emerged from section II is compared with
MCML based XOR. Finally the concluding remarks are given
in Section IV.
II. INVESTIGATION OF SIGNIFICANT XOR CIRCUITS
The efficient design of XOR circuit is key requirement for
many complex circuits as these circuits are developed using
XOR circuit as their basic units. Different XOR circuits are
thus analyzed thoroughly in this work.
Fig. 1 shows the circuit diagram of 4T PTL based XOR
circuit [6]. This circuit is devised using static CMOS inverter.
The availability of the inverter gives signal level restoration
and improves the driving capability of the circuit . However,
output levels of this circuit are not appreciably matched. This
is the demerit of this circuit.
High Speed 8-transistor (HS-8T) XOR circuit shown in
Fig. 2 [7] consists of transmission gates. The circuit delivers
high speed of operation, but has comparatively high power