Trends in the Utilization of Medical
Imaging From 2003 to 2011: Clinical
Encounters Offer a Complementary
Patient-Centered Focus
Martey S. Dodoo, PhD, Richard Duszak Jr, MD, Danny R. Hughes, PhD
Purpose: The aim of this study was to investigate trends in utilization and spending for medical imaging,
using medical visits resulting in imaging as a novel metric of utilization.
Methods: Utilization and spending for medical imaging were examined using (1) Medicare Part B claims data
from 2003 to 2011 to measure per-enrollee spending and (2) household component events data on the elderly
Medicare-age population from the Medical Expenditure Panel Survey from 2003 to 2010 to measure utilization
as a function of clinical encounters.
Results: Annual health spending and Medicare payments for imaging for the elderly population grew from
$294 per enrollee in 2003 to $418 in 2006 and had declined to $390 by 2011. Over this entire time, however,
annual medical visits by a similar Medicare-age (65 years old) population resulting in imaging trended
consistently downward, from 12.8% in 2003 to 10.6% in 2011.
Conclusions: Despite early growth and then more recent declines in average Medicare spending per enrollee
since 2003, the percentage of patient encounters resulting in medical imaging has significantly and consistently
declined nationwide. Spending alone is thus an incomplete measure of changes in the role and utilization of
medical imaging in overall patient care. As policymakers focus on medical imaging, a thoughtful analysis of
payment policy influencing imaging utilization, and its role in concurrent and downstream patient care, will be
critical to ensure appropriate patient access.
Key Words: Medical imaging, utilization visits, Medicare, PSPS Master Files, MEPS, program spending
J Am Coll Radiol 2013;10:507-512. Copyright © 2013 American College of Radiology
INTRODUCTION
Recent studies [1-3] have attempted to draw attention to
the earlier growth and subsequent recent slowing in both
medical imaging utilization and Medicare program
spending on imaging. In ongoing efforts to curtail health
care expenditures, policymakers have tended to focus on
growth before 2006, when spending on imaging grew
rapidly. Most have neglected more recent declines, which
could in part be attributed to the Deficit Reduction Act
(DRA) of 2005 [4], which markedly reduced payments
for the technical components of many imaging services.
In the past few years, that single legislative effort has
seemingly had an enormous impact on Medicare Part
B program payments to physicians for medical imag-
ing [5]. However, it is not clear what effect, if any, it
has had on the utilization of those services in the
context of concurrent and downstream patient care.
This is particularly important because there have been
subsequent additional threats to physician payments
for medical imaging [6], which could have implica-
tions for patient care [7]. With the more recent possi-
bility of sequestration (ie, mandatory spending cuts as
part of the Budget Control Act), physician payments
may be further reduced [3]. Moreover, additional
threats exist to Medicare payments for all physician
services as part of ongoing uncertainty regarding the
sustainable growth rate calculation methodology [2],
which could substantively affect imaging services. A
failure to understand the changes in utilization that
may accompany these potential payment reductions
could ultimately produce adverse effects on patient
care regardless of whether the intended cost contain-
ment goals are realized.
Ongoing analysis of trends in medical imaging has
tended to focus primarily on either utilization (most
Harvey L. Neiman Health Policy Institute, Reston, Virginia.
Corresponding author and reprints: Martey S. Dodoo, PhD, Harvey L.
Neiman Health Policy Institute, 1891 Preston White Drive, Reston, VA
20191; e-mail: mdodoo@neimanhpi.org.
© 2013 American College of Radiology
0091-2182/13/$36.00
●
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jacr.2013.02.023
507