Mobbing against nurses in the workplace
in Turkey
S.Y. Efe
1
MSN & S. Ayaz
2
PhD
1 Specialist, 2 Assistant Professor, Nursing Department, Gazi University Faculty of Health Sciences, Ankara, Turkey
EFE S.Y.& AYAZ S.(2010) Mobbing against nurses in the workplace in Turkey. International Nursing Review
57, 328–334
Aim: The aim of the study was to determine whether the nurses have been exposed to mobbing or not, and to
reveal the causes of the mobbing between 3 November 2008 and 31 December 2008.
Methods: This research was a mixed method study involving survey and focus group interviews. The sample
was calculated using sample calculation formula, and 206 nurses were included in the survey study. Four focus
group interviews were later carried out with 16 nurses. The survey method and semi-structured question form
were used to collect data. The percentage and chi-square were used to evaluate the quantitative data, and for
the analysis of the qualitative data, descriptive analyses were made through direct quotations from the nurses’
statements.
Findings: According to the mobbing scale, 9.7% of the nurses had been exposed to mobbing, but according
to their own declarations, 33% had been exposed. Some of the nurses (25.2%) who expressed that they had
been exposed to mobbing reported that the executor of mobbing was the head nurse and 9.2% said that the
reason for mobbing was‘communication problems’. Nurses under 25 years of age and those who work in
intensive care units are apparently exposed to mobbing more frequently than others (P < 0.05).
Conclusions: It is suggested that head nurses’ mobbing behaviours should be determined and they should be
educated about leadership. Nurses should be educated about assertiveness to prevent mobbing. The necessary
measures should be adopted to solve the‘communication problems’, which are shown as a major reason for
mobbing.
Keywords: Harassment, Mobbing, Nurse, Turkey, Workplace
Introduction
Mobbing is the activity of a person to force someone out of the
workplace through rumour, innuendo, intimidation, humilia-
tion, discrediting and isolation (Davenport et al. 2003). Emo-
tional harassment behaviours are difficult to determine because
they are mostly psychological rather than physical. They are
composed of numerous systematic events that are very small and
can be unimportant and meaningless when considered in isola-
tion. Usually, the executor is not a single person, and the activity
is usually prepared secretly, behind closed doors. For this reason,
the verification of mobbing is practically impossible. However,
the victim’s quitting work, making big mistakes or giving
extreme reactions because of pressure happen publicly (Baykal
2005).
In recent years, people who work in the education, social ser-
vices and health-care sectors have been increasingly exposed to
emotional pressure, both in developed and developing countries
(Chappell & Di Martino 2006). Hospitals are crowded and
intense workplaces. Hard working conditions, shift working,
insufficient wages (especially in government institutions) and
injustices in profession advancement can trigger emotional
harassment (Davenport et al. 2003). Research shows that nurses
Correspondence address: Sultan Ayaz, Gazi Üniversitesi Sag ˘lık Bilimleri Fakültesi
Hems ¸irelik Bölümü, 06500 Bes ¸evler, Ankara, Turkey; Tel: 0090-312216-26-23;
Fax: 0090-312216-26-36; E-mail: sultan@gazi.edu.tr.
Original Article
© 2010 The Authors. International Nursing Review © 2010 International Council of Nurses 328