357
Journal of Adolescent & Adult Literacy 52(4)
December 2008/January 2009
© 2008 International Reading Association
(pp. 357–363)
Professional
Resources
Bonner Slayton
George Hruby
doi:10.1598/JAAL.52.4.9
Reviews
Reclaiming Reluctant Writers: How to Encourage Students
to Face Their Fears and Master the Essential Traits of Good
Writers
Kellie Buis. 2007. Portland, ME: Pembroke. 128 pp. US$18.50.
Kellie Buis tackles the issue of motivating reluctant writers by giving teachers
ideas to help students who have become “disillusioned” because they have “little
power over what they can say and write” (p. 6). Many times these students ap-
pear withdrawn from classroom literacy instruction. Buis defines reluctant writ-
ers as “students in grades 3 to 9 with difficulties coordinating knowledge on a
page” (p. 6). The book is written for teachers in these grade levels, but the ideas
that she gives are geared more toward teachers of adolescent writers. According
to the introduction, reluctant writers are a large group of any classroom, and
teachers can identify success factors with these students by focusing on making
reluctant writers more engaged in the writing process. Literacy teachers will find
her ability to explain the myths and realities surrounding reluctant writers help-
ful in direct writing instruction.
Each chapter starts with an anecdote from the author and then moves into
three areas: common myths that teachers may have about reluctant writers or
writing in general, reality checks of what writers really think and how to meet
their needs, and challenges to modify pedagogy in the classroom. While this
format is somewhat difficult to understand at first, it becomes easier after reading
the first few chapters.
Buis argues that writing classrooms are not the ideal places “in which we can
expect students to write well” and that it is important to build enabling environ-
ments for students to succeed. This can be done by granting students real-world
opportunities to write (“authentic writing”) and by encouraging teachers to “re-
conceptualize our teaching approach” by developing action plans followed by
“open writing time” (pp.10–11). This approach allows students opportunities
to have confidence in what they write by having teachers plan “many wonder-
ful out-of-desk experiences” (p. 11), including a balance of direct teaching and
process writing.
Writers need fun, experiential writing that nurtures a “discovery and flow
of ideas” (p. 19). By allowing reluctant writers to use the world around them as
writing prompts, teachers give these students meaning and reasons for writing.
For example, in an assignment about a “scar story,” students write about the
different ways in which one can get a scar. Many reluctant writers (especially
boys) can see how real-life accidents can be written into personal narratives. A