Physico-Chemical and Sensory Quality Criteria of
Green Beans ( Phaseolus vulgaris , L.)
C. Martínez*, G. Ros, M.J. Periago, G. López, J. Ortu ˜ no and F. Rincón
C. Martínez, G. Ros, M.J. Periago, G. López, J. Ortu ˜ no: Department of Food Science, Veterinary Faculty,
University of Murcia, E-30071 Murcia (Spain)
F. Rincón: Department of Food Science, Veterinary Faculty, University of C´ ordoba, E-30100 C ´ ordoba (Spain)
(Received September 5, 1994; accepted February 23, 1995)
Two varieties of green beans ( Phaseolus vulgaris L .), one round and the other flat at different stages of maturity were analysed
for nine physico-chemical and seven sensory variables. Moisture content, chlorophyll, alcohol insoluble solids, soluble solids and
total acidity were found to be of relevance for measuring the growth and maturity of round green beans. A lcohol insoluble solids,
soluble solids, and total acidity increased significantly during development, while moisture and chlorophyll showed an opposite
trend. Fibrousness, juiciness and hardness were the most important sensory variables for the overall acceptance of the cooked
product. Multi-dimensional scaling revealed a weak relationship between the sensory attributes and the physico-chemical
variables which define maturity.
©1995 Academic Press Limited
Introduction
Quality is one of the most defined terms in use in the
food industry today but it is also perhaps one of the
most confusing because it is used for several distinct
purposes. The most widely used concept is the fitness
for purpose sense which relates to the ability of a
product to satisfy a given need (1). The quality of many
processed fruits and vegetables is markedly influenced
by the physiological maturity of the raw materials at the
time of harvest. This maturity is often determined by
visual inspection, but in quality control, there is a need
to have objective methods for quality determination
(2,3). Alcohol insoluble solids, soluble solids, moisture
content, colour and tenderometer value have been
found of relevance for measuring pea growth and
maturity (4). Legumes hold an important place in the
Mediterranean diet, providing a high level of energy
from carbohydrates and proteins and a low level of
energy from fats. A remarkable increase in the con-
sumption of green legumes has occurred in the Medi-
terranean countries over the last few years, mainly due
to the availability of frozen legumes (5). The green bean
( Phaseolus vulgaris L.) is relatively fast maturing crop
in which the whole seed pod is harvested immature for
processing by canning and freezing. The length of the
developing seed within the pod has proved the most
satisfactory method for measuring maturity (6), how-
ever, physico-chemical changes have been given little
attention in the literature.
Sensory attributes (appearance, texture, aroma and
flavour) are a function of the physico-chemical compo-
sition of the vegetable (7), which is influenced by the
quality and composition of the raw materials. By
determining which product sensory attributes are most
important to consumers, we can focus development
efforts on satisfying their expectations (8). Knowledge
of relationships between food composition and sensory
attributes has been helpful in selection of better sweet
corn genotype for the food industry (9), in prediction of
sensory quality from physico-chemical measurements
in frozen peas (10), or simply in the commercial
classification of canned grapefruit based on analytical
and sensory properties (11).
The main purpose of this paper was to study the
physical and chemical changes in two varieties of green
bean to predict their maturity level. The second aim was
to obtain consumer acceptance data and explore
correlations between sensory and instrumental results
using multi-dimensional scaling.
Materials and Methods
M aterials
Two cultivars of green bean ( Phaseolus vulgaris L.) one
round (STRIKE) and the other flat (BINA) (Asgrow
Seed Company, Barcelona, Spain) were grown in a
greenhouse and hand harvested in June 1992 at the
Agricultural Experimental Centre of the University of
Murcia (southeast Spain). STRIKE cultivar was classi-
fied by pod diameter following the Seed Company’s
recommendations into four sizes: 1 ( ≤ 6.5 mm), 2 (from
6.6 to 8 mm), 3 (from 8.1 to 9 mm) and 4 (from 9.1 to *To whom correspondence should be addressed.
Lebensm.-Wiss. u.-Technol., 28, 515–520 (1995)
0023-6438/95/050515 + 06 $12.00/0 ©1995 Academic Press Limited
515