Journal of Vegetation Science 24 (2013) 506–517
Does soil nitrogen availability mediate the response of
grassland composition to water regime?
Yoseph N. Araya, David J. Gowing & N. Dise
Keywords
Air-filled pore space; Grassland composition;
Ion exchange resin; Meadow vegetation;
Microbial community composition; Nitrogen
mineralization; Phospholipid fatty acids (PLFA)
Nomenclature
Rodwell (1992)
Received 13 September 2010
Accepted 18 August 2012
Co-ordinating Editor: Helge Bruelheide
Araya, Y.N. (corresponding author,
y.n.araya@open.ac.uk) & Gowing, D.J.
(d.j.gowing@open.ac.uk): Department of
Environment, Earth and Ecosystems, The Open
University, Walton Hall, Milton Keynes,
MK7 6AA, UK
Dise, N. (n.dise@mmu.ac.uk): Department of
Environmental and Geographical Sciences,
Manchester Metropolitan University,
Manchester, M1 5GD, UK
Abstract
Questions: How is the composition of wet meadow plant communities
influenced by water regime? What controls soil nitrogen (N) availability along a
gentle soil water regime gradient? Is vegetation response to subtle changes in soil
water regime mediated by N availability?
Location: Cricklade, Wiltshire, southwest England.
Methods: A field survey of community composition and soil N availability was
conducted along a gentle gradient of water table depth (mean water table depth
between 25 and 70 cm) at a species-rich hay meadow in southwest England.
This study was complemented by a controlled mescosm study undertaken at
water table depths between 5 and 45 cm, and a controlled laboratory N mineral-
ization study with water tension varying between 0 and 100 cm (0–10 kPa), the
latter augmented with a microbial community study.
Results: The field, mesocosm and laboratory studies showed that the soil N min-
eralization rate and N availability responded to water regime. In particular, the
N mineralization rate strongly declined when the soil air-filled pore space
dropped below 10% of total soil volume. In the field, plant cover distribution
(individual species as well as functional groups) correlated with increase in soil
water table depth (r = 0.86 and r = 0.89 for graminoids and forbs, respec-
tively) and soil N availability (r = 0.77 and r = 0.85, respectively). A switch in
dominance between forbs and graminoids occurred at a mean water table depth
of 55 cm and mean soil inorganic N of 20 mgkg
1
). Study of the soil microbial
community composition in the mesocosms, using phospholipid fatty acid (PLFA)
signatures, showed that microbial community composition was also significantly
influenced by soil water status.
Conclusions: We show that soil moisture content and soil aeration control the
availability of N, a limiting nutrient, in species-rich wet meadows. The mecha-
nism is linked to changes in suitability of the soil water regime for microbially
mediated N mineralization. Maintaining the water regime is therefore critical
because adjustment of the hydrological niche also conditions species’ responses
along the N availability gradient. This could subsequently prove a useful tool for
conservation managers trying to sustain a target vegetation type.
Introduction
Plant communities in wet meadows are strongly
influenced by the depth and annual variation in the water
table (Hayati & Proctor 1990; Gowing & Youngs 1997;
Dwire et al. 2004). Experimental and observational field
studies have shown that minor shifts in soil water regime
may play a significant role in the composition of plant
communities (e.g. Gowing & Spoor 1998; Silvertown et al.
1999; Van Oorschot et al. 2000; Leyer 2005). In spite of
this recognition, relatively little attention has been paid to
the mechanism of how the water regime influences plant
composition, and thus the distribution of species along gra-
dients in soil water regime (Levine et al. 1998; Yu & Eh-
renfeld 2010). It is known that in many natural
environments soil nutrient availability is the major factor
Journal of Vegetation Science
506 Doi: 10.1111/j.1654-1103.2012.01481.x © 2012 International Association for Vegetation Science