Optimal amplitude quadrature control of an optical squeezer using an
integral LQG approach
S. Z. Sayed Hassen and I. R. Petersen
Abstract— Squeezed states of light possess an asymmetric
noise distribution whereby the uncertainty in one quadrature
is less than the standard quantum noise limit. These states can
be generated through a nonlinear optical process in an optical
parametric oscillator (OPO). In this paper, we model such an
optical squeezer and design an LQG controller which includes
integral action to optimize the level of squeezing achieved in
one of the quadratures of the fundamental optical field.
I. I NTRODUCTION
Nonlinear processes arising in quantum optics have proved
useful in checking the counter-intuitive predictions of the
theory of quantum mechanics. One of the simplest nonlinear
optical processes, second harmonic generation (SHG), has
been extensively studied and found to be a potential source
of squeezed states of light. Squeezed light has an asymmetric
quadrature noise distribution, with one quadrature having less
noise than the standard quantum noise limit (SQL). This
feature of squeezed states makes them particularly useful for
applications such as gravitational wave detection (see [1]),
where the use of squeezed light allows for a reduction of the
laser power necessary to achieve a given signal to noise ratio.
Other promising applications include quantum cryptography
and optical communications. One of the main problems
associated with the generation of squeezed states is due to
what is known in the physics literature as “dephasing”; see
[2]. Dephasing adds considerable phase noise to both the
fundamental and second-harmonic fields inside an optical
resonator cavity, and if unaccounted for, can completely
destroy any squeezing achieved. This noise (also referred to
as laser phase noise) occurs predominantly at low frequencies
and can be modelled as a constant DC offset disturbance
acting on the system.
In this paper, we address the problem of optimally squeez-
ing a specific quadrature of light using an optimal parametric
oscillator (OPO). We apply integral LQG control to an OPO
driven by two optical fields
ˆ
A
in
and
ˆ
B
in
; see Fig. 1. We
include integral action as the standard LQG technique is
not able to deal with the type of disturbance present in
our application. One of the optical input fields (
ˆ
B
in
) is
controlled by a mirror connected to a piezoelectric actuator.
The actuator adjusts the phase quadrature of the optical
field, thus minimizing the effect of phase noise and other
classical sources of noise. This in turn regulates the phase
angles of the fundamental and second-harmonic intra-cavity
This work was supported by the Australian Research Council
S. Z. Sayed Hassen and I. R. Petersen are with the School of Engineer-
ing and Information Technology at the University of New South Wales,
Canberra, ACT 2600, Australia. sayed.hassen@gmail.com
fields, allowing for squeezing of light in a spatial quadrature.
The available measurement is the phase quadrature of the
output second harmonic field
ˆ
B
out
which is measured using
the homodyne detection method; see [3]. One important
feature of our approach is that we propose a control law that
minimizes the noise in one quadrature of the fundamental
output field using both measurement and actuation on the
second harmonic field. The complete model we use for
the controller design and subsequent simulations is derived
from the linearized quantum dynamics of the OPO (optical
subsystem) and from the model of a piezoelectric actuator
(mechanical subsystem) typically found in a quantum optics
laboratory.
A similar control design approach to the one presented
here was investigated in [4] where the laser phase noise
was modelled as (approximately) integrated white noise.
Whilst this approximation of the phase noise was suitable for
simulation purposes and to expose our ideas with regards to
the specific problem, it turns out that the controller obtained
in [4] is not appropriate in practice as it does not include
integral action. Integral action is necessary to counteract any
DC offset. The requirement to minimize the variance of the
quadrature of the fundamental output field is reflected in
an LQG cost functional and the need for integral action
is included by modifying the control signals and the cost
functional appropriately. Typical parameter values for an
experimental squeezer are used for the controller design and
we validate our design through simulation.
II. THE OPTICAL PARAMETRIC AMPLIFICATION
PROBLEM
The optical system under consideration consists of a
second-order nonlinear optical medium enclosed within an
optical resonator [3]. Materials showing second-order non-
linearities χ
(2)
have the ability to couple a fundamental field
(f ) to a second harmonic field (2f ). This coupling forms
the basis of operation of the OPO through nonlinear optical
interaction and feedback resulting in the build-up of the
waves in a process similar to that seen in a laser cavity. The
output beams thus become quantum correlated producing
squeezed light; ; see, e.g., [5], [6] for more details.
Fig. 1 shows our setup used for the OPO control problem.
The aim is to maximize the amplitude quadrature squeezing
of the fundamental optical field observed at a given operat-
ing point by optimally suppressing the different sources of
noise feeding into the system. This aim is translated into a
specific quadratic cost functional to define an LQG optimal
control problem, the underlying assumption being that the
2010 IEEE International Conference on Control Applications
Part of 2010 IEEE Multi-Conference on Systems and Control
Yokohama, Japan, September 8-10, 2010
978-1-4244-5363-4/10/$26.00 ©2010 IEEE 286