A Practical Guide to Self-Sustaining Point-of-Care
Ultrasound Education Programs in
Resource-Limited Settings
Patricia C. Henwood, MD*; David C. Mackenzie, MD; Joshua S. Rempell, MD, MPH; Alice F. Murray, MD;
Megan M. Leo, MD; Anthony J. Dean, MD; Andrew S. Liteplo, MD; Vicki E. Noble, MD
*Corresponding Author. E-mail: trish.henwood@gmail.com.
The value of point-of-care ultrasound education in resource-limited settings is increasingly recognized, though little
guidance exists on how to best construct a sustainable training program. Herein we offer a practical overview of core factors
to consider when developing and implementing a point-of-care ultrasound education program in a resource-limited setting.
Considerations include analysis of needs assessment findings, development of locally relevant curriculum, access to
ultrasound machines and related technological and financial resources, quality assurance and follow-up plans, strategic
partnerships, and outcomes measures. Well-planned education programs in these settings increase the potential for long-
term influence on clinician skills and patient care. [Ann Emerg Med. 2014;-:1-9.]
0196-0644/$-see front matter
Copyright © 2014 by the American College of Emergency Physicians.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.annemergmed.2014.04.013
BACKGROUND
In resource-limited settings, diagnostic imaging modalities are
often constrained, frequently limited to plain film radiography. A
number of articles have demonstrated the value of point-of-care
ultrasonography in such settings.
1-3
Point-of-care ultrasonography
provides a low-cost, efficient method to aid in the diagnosis and
management of many conditions in resource-limited settings,
including maternal and peripartum care, heart failure, diarrheal
illness, tuberculosis, and trauma.
4-6
It can also decrease procedural
complications.
7
It allows one caregiver to perform, interpret, and
act on a diagnostic test, which can save both time and resources.
8,9
Recent articles have described the use of point-of-care
ultrasonography in Rwanda, Zambia, Liberia, Ghana, Haiti, and
Tanzania.
4,10-15
As ultrasound machines become more portable
and affordable, coupled with increasing capacity to transmit
digital images for remote review, the introduction of point-of-
care ultrasonography may have a transformative effect on health
care in resource-limited settings. As a result, there is increasing
interest in delivering ultrasound education programs in low- and
middle-income countries.
4,13-17
However, there is little
published guidance on how to establish effective and sustainable
point-of-care ultrasound programs in resource-limited settings.
18
In accordance with available literature and international
experience of the authors, we aim to provide a practical overview
of how to design and implement an ultrasound education
curriculum leading to the establishment of a sustainable resource-
limited setting ultrasonography program.
Our approach to program development is directed at achieving
a transition from initial educational initiatives, likely supported
by educators primarily from outside the training site, to the
development of a stable, locally administered, point-of-care
ultrasonography program with the capacity to provide training
for other users in the resource-limited settings. This model
has been used in a range of locations and disciplines of medicine
and surgery.
19-23
We emphasize the importance of beginning
this process with a needs assessment to ensure a locally
appropriate curriculum, and describe other core aspects of
program development, including trainee selection, essential
partnerships, equipment selection and maintenance, initial
training implementation, competence assessment, quality
assurance, research, funding, and logistics.
NEEDS ASSESSMENT
The critical first step to resource-limited settings program
development is a thorough needs assessment,
24-27
which ensures
that new ultrasound programs will be tailored to local capacity
and clinical requirements. Factors to consider include the patient
population, prospective trainees, local and regional resources of
the health care system, and identification of other stakeholders.
Figure 1 illustrates an overview of the needs assessment process
and pathways to program development.
Defining Objectives
The needs assessment for a point-of-care ultrasound
program aims to define and prioritize clinical needs and
anticipate the resources required to meet them.
27
Unmet clinical
needs and objectives can be determined by collecting
information from stakeholders, including patients, clinicians,
administrators, and government agencies. Needs assessment
methods might include questionnaires, structured interviews,
focus group discussions, direct observation of clinicians in their
Volume -, no. - : - 2014 Annals of Emergency Medicine 1
IMAGING/CONCEPTS