IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON COMMUNICATIONS, VOL. 56, NO. 8, AUGUST 2008 1241
Bounds on the Distribution of a Sum of
Correlated Lognormal Random Variables and Their Application
C. Tellambura, Senior Member, IEEE
Abstract—The cumulative distribution function (cdf) of a sum
of correlated or even independent lognormal random variables
(RVs), which is of wide interest in wireless communications,
remains unsolved despite long standing efforts. Several cdf
approximations are thus widely used. This letter derives bounds
for the cdf of a sum of 2 or 3 arbitrarily correlated lognormal
RVs and of a sum of any number of equally-correlated lognormal
RVs. The bounds are single-fold integrals of readily computable
functions and extend previously known bounds for independent
lognormal summands. An improved set of bounds are also
derived which are expressed as 2-fold integrals. For correlated
lognormal fading channels, new expressions are derived for the
moments of the output SNR and amount of fading for maximal
ratio combining (MRC), selection combining (SC) and equal gain
combining (EGC) and outage probability expressions for SC.
Index Terms—Amount of fading, cochannel interference, log-
normal distribution, diversity combining.
I. I NTRODUCTION
A
LOGNORMAL power sum of type
I =
n
i=1
e
Xi
(1)
where each X
i
is a Gaussian random variable (RV) appears
pervasively in wireless communications. Applications include
modeling and assessing cochannel interference, evaluating
coverage for cellular mobile networks and modeling fading
and shadowing [1], [2], and the book by Aitchison and Brown
[3] lists over 100 applications. Nevertheless, no exact closed-
form formula for the distribution of I is known. Even the
characteristic function (chf) of a lognormal RV is not known
in closed-form. Thus, several approximations have been de-
veloped such as moment matching [4], cumulant matching [5]
and recursive methods [6] - for comparisons see [2] [7]. For
more recent results on lognormal sums the reader is referred
to [8]–[17].
Although independent lognormal sums have been widely
studied, applications where correlation among the summands
in (1) exists occur just as frequently. Therefore, the distribu-
tion of correlated lognormal sums has applications such as
macro-diversity systems [18], soft handoff algorithms, single
frequency networks and others. Moment matching or cumulant
matching approximations that have been developed for inde-
pendent lognormal sums can also be extended for correlated
lognormal sums [19]–[21].
Paper approved by F. Santucci, the Editor for Wireless System Performance
of the IEEE Communications Society. Manuscript received December 15,
2003; revised September 16, 2006. This work has been supported in part by
NSERC and iCORE.
C. Tellambura is with the Department of Electrical and Computer Engi-
neering, University of Alberta, Edmonton, AB, Canada T6G 2V4 (e-mail:
chintha@ece.ualberta.ca).
Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/TCOMM.2008.030947.
In this paper, we derive bounds for the cdf of a sum of two
or three correlated lognormal RVs with arbitrary correlation
and of a sum of any number of equally-correlated lognormal
RVs. Several previously derived bounds are shown to be
special cases of these. A further set of improved bounds
(2-fold integrals) are derived. The simulation results confirm
the tightness of these bounds. Although diversity combiners
such as maximal ratio combining (MRC), selection combining
(SC) and equal gain combining (EGC) have been widely
studied over various channel models, their performance over
correlated lognormal channels is not available in detail. For
correlated lognormal fading channels, we also derive new
expressions for the moments of the output SNR and amount of
fading for MRC, SC and EGC and outage probability expres-
sions for SC. For this development, we utilize S-function and
T-function [22], [23], which are generalizations of the well-
known Q-function and are not known widely in the wireless
community. These results facilitate the rapid evaluation of the
performance of diversity schemes over correlated lognormal
channels, where no results have been published for diversity
order more than two.
Our bounds generalize previously published bounds for
independent lognormal sums by Slimane [24] and Farley’s
lower bound (or approximation) for independent lognormal
sums [1] [2]. Abu-Dayya & Beaulieu [19] provide a detailed
analysis of outage probabilities in the presence of multiple
correlated lognormal interferers, using Wilkinson’s approach,
Schwartz and Yeh’s approach and cumulant matching. Outage
probability estimation in the presence of multiple lognormal
components has been discussed by Ligeti [21]. Pratesi et al
[20] treat outage analysis in mobile radio with generically
correlated lognormal interferers. They extend several approx-
imations for the independent case to those for the generically
correlated case. Berggren and Slimane [25], by applying the
arithmetic-geometric mean inequality, give a lower bound
expressed by a single Q-function. Our work is different from
all these in that we develop bounds for the correlated case and
analyze diversity schemes. A detailed performance analysis
of dual-branch diversity schemes over correlated lognormal
fading has been developed by Alouini & Simon [26]. Our
results generalize some of their results to multibranch (n> 2)
diversity systems.
This paper is organized as follows. Section II lists several
relevant results for the multinormal distribution. Section III
develops bounds for sums of correlated lognormal variables.
Section IV derives the performance of SC, MRC and EGC
receivers over correlated lognormal channels and Section V
concludes the paper.
0090-6778/08$25.00 c 2008 IEEE
Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSITY OF ALBERTA. Downloaded on December 17, 2009 at 15:11 from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
"©2008 IEEE. Personal use of this material is permitted. However, permission to reprint/republish this material for advertising or promotional purposes or for creating new
collective works for resale or redistribution to servers or lists, or to reuse any copyrighted component of this work in other works must be obtained from the IEEE."