Entomopathogenic fungi of the oil palm pest, Zophiuma butawengi
(Fulgoromorpha: Lophopidae), and potential for use as biological
control agents
Deane N Woruba,
1
* Michael J Priest,
2
Charles F Dewhurst,
3
Catherine W Gitau,
1
Murray J Fletcher,
2
Helen I Nicol
1
and Geoff M Gurr
1
1
EH Graham Centre, Charles Sturt University, Orange, NSW 2800, Australia.
2
EH Graham Centre, NSW Department of Primary Industry, Orange Agricultural Institute, Orange, NSW 2800,
Australia.
3
PNG Oil Palm Research Association, Kimbe 621, WNB, Papua New Guinea.
Abstract Oil palm, Elaeis guineensis Jacq., is an important cash crop in Papua New Guinea. Production is currently
under threat from Finschhafen disorder caused by the planthopper Zophiuma butawengi (Heller), a native pest
of coconut. The need for a non-chemical strategy to manage Z. butawengi is high because the industry is
committed to sustainable production. One possible option is the development of biological control using
entomopathogenic fungi, and this study aimed to assess the scope for such a technology. Field collections
extending over three regions of West New Britain in the 2010 monsoon season yielded 38 mycosed cadavers.
Only three yielded entomopathogenic fungi: two of Hirsutella citriformis Speare and one each of Metarhizium
flavoviride var. minus Rombach, Humber and D.W. Roberts, and Purpureocillium lilacinum (Thom) Luangsa-
ard, Houbraken, Hywel-Jones and Samson. The pathogenicity of each isolate to Z. butawengi was confirmed
in a laboratory study. M. flavoviride var. minus killed Z. butawengi significantly more rapidly over the course
of a 15-day period, and day 7 mortality was significantly greater than in water or nil control treatments. Given
this pathogenic fungus was readily culturable and congenerics are used in other biological control treatments,
it merits further investigation as a potential inundative entomopathogenic agent against Z. butawengi.
Key words Planthopper, oil palm, Metarhizium flavoviride var. minus, Hirsutella citriformis, Purpureocillium lilacinum,
pathogenicity.
INTRODUCTION
Oil palm, Elaeis guineensis Jacq. (Arecaceae), was introduced
into Papua New Guinea (PNG) in the 1920s, but the industry did
not develop until 1967 (Allen et al. 2009). In 2010, the value of
palm oil represented 46% of all major agricultural export com-
modities of PNG, making oil palm the most valuable agricul-
tural commodity in PNG (Bank of Papua New Guinea 2011).
The oil palm industry is now under threat by Finschhafen
disorder (FD) caused by the planthopper, Zophiuma butawengi
(Heller) (= Z. lobulata Ghauri) (Fulgoromorpha: Lophopidae)
(Gitau et al. 2011a,b). FD was first recorded on coconut, Cocos
nucifera L. (Arecaceae), and is also found on betel nut, Areca
catechu L. (Arecaceae) (Ghauri 1967; Smith 1980a,b; Prior
et al. 2001; Page 2004; Gitau et al. 2011b). These palm species
play important roles in the livelihoods of the rural population
(Allen et al. 2009). The coconut palm has a long history in PNG
as an important source of food and as a cash crop (Allen et al.
2009). Betel nut is an important traditional plant and more
recently has become an important cash crop within the local
economy in PNG (Allen et al. 2009). The threat Z. butawengi
poses to oil palm is probably the most significant. Although the
loss of oil palm because of Z. butawengi has not been quanti-
fied, losses on coconut were estimated to be a third of the crop,
with a further 80% of coconut palms affected and 10% of
affected palms died (Smith 1980b). Losses to oil palm of even
a fraction of this magnitude would be economically devastating
for PNG.
FD was first described as a ‘plague infestation of coconut’
when a major outbreak affected palms in Finschhafen (Fig. 1),
Morobe Province (MP), PNG (Ghauri 1967), hence the name
‘Finschhafen Disorder’. Fronds of the coconut become
chlorotic and later necrotic from the tip back to the base of the
frond. Despite regular sightings of Z. butawengi on coconut
and betel nut along the north-eastern coastline on the island of
New Guinea between Alotau, Milne Bay Province (MBP) and
Finschhafen, MP (Smith 1980a), the spread of FD has been
slow and sporadic. Apart from Finschhafen, further reports of
FD on coconut have been made from Popondetta in the North-
ern Province (NP), Losuia Island in MBP, and Banaule and
Mai villages in West New Britain Province (WNBP) (Smith
1980a; Prior et al. 2001). During the infestation at Banaule and
Mai villages, FD symptoms were also observed in neighbour-
ing blocks of oil palm (Prior et al. 2001). Since then, there
have been increasing reports of FD on oil palm in WNBP, *nabre3@gmail.com
Austral Entomology (2013) ••, ••–••
© 2013 Australian Entomological Society doi:10.1111/aen.12073