Journal of Tropical Ecology (2011) 27:35–49. Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2010
doi:10.1017/S0266467410000611
Successional trends in soil seed banks of abandoned pastures of a
Neotropical dry region
Susana Maza-Villalobos
∗
, Celina Lemus-Herrera† and Miguel Mart´ ınez-Ramos
∗,1
∗
Centro de Investigaciones en Ecosistemas, Universidad Nacional Aut ´ onoma de M ´ exico, Antigua Carretera a P ´ atzcuaro # 8701, Col. Ex-Hacienda de San Jos ´ e de la
Huerta, CP 58190, Morelia, Michoac ´ an, M ´ exico
† Facultad de Biolog´ ıa, Universidad Michoacana de San Nicol ´ as de Hidalgo, Ciudad Universitaria Av. Fco. J. M ´ ugica S/N., CP 58030, Morelia, Michoac ´ an, M ´ exico
(Accepted 18 September 2010)
Abstract: A chronosequence was used to study seed-bank communities during the first 12 y of tropical-dry-forest
regeneration in abandoned pastures in Chamela, Mexico. Prediction that seeds of woody species replace those of
herbaceous species during succession was tested and mechanisms of species replacement (facilitation, tolerance,
inhibition) were assessed. Four successional categories (three sites each) were considered: pasture (0–1 y since
abandonment), early (3–5 y), intermediate (10–12 y), and old-growth forest. At the end of the dry season, 20
cylindrical soil samples (10 cm diameter, 15 cm depth) were randomly obtained within a 20 × 50-m plot in each site.
Seeds ≥1 mm were counted and identified. Overall, 2941 seeds and 102 morphospecies (52 taxonomically identified)
were recorded. Seed bank density reduced, species diversity remained fairly constant and seeds of herbaceous species
were replaced by those of woody species over the chronosequence. A clear species-by-species replacement pattern was
detected, as expected under a mechanism of succession by facilitation. Twelve years after abandonment, a diverse seed
bank of woody species did exist, indicating a fast recovery of the tropical-dry-forest regenerative potential; nonetheless,
the structure and composition of the seed bank was still different from that in the old-growth forest.
Key Words: Chamela–Cuixmala, chronosequence, Mexico, natural regeneration, regenerative communities, secondary
succession, tropical dry forest
INTRODUCTION
Tropical dry forests (TDF) are greatly threatened by their
conversion to agricultural land, making the future of this
biome largely dependent on conservation of remaining
old-growth forests and regeneration and restoration of
secondary forests (Dirzo et al. 2010, S ´ anchez-Azofeifa et al.
2009). This posits a challenge because understanding the
ecological factors, processes and mechanisms that allow
TDF regeneration is far from being complete (Quesada
et al. 2009). For example, currently no more than five
published studies on TDF seed-bank communities in old-
fields exist (Gonz ´ alez-Rivas et al. 2009, Lemenih & Teketay
2006, Miller 1999, Rico-Gray & Garc´ ıa-Franco 1992,
Vieira & Scariot 2006).
Colonizing herbaceous plants are highly dependent on
light to produce abundant seeds, which usually are able
to stay dormant in the soil for long periods (Fenner 1985).
1
Corresponding author. Email: mmartine@oikos.unam.mx
Seed bank density of such herbaceous plants is expected
to decline as TDF succession advances and light resources
reduce in the understorey. In contrast, seeds of most
woody species lack prolonged dormancy and suffer high
predation rates (Briones-Salas et al. 2006, Garwood 1989,
Janzen 1981, Khurana & Singh 2001), which makes their
abundance in the soil largely dependent on local seed
rain (
´
Alvarez-Buylla & Mart´ ınez-Ramos 1990, Dalling &
Denslow 1998). Thus, the abundance and diversity of
seeds of woody species in the soil is expected to increase
as more reproductive woody plants become established
during succession.
The temporal changes undergone by seed-bank
communities may allow the exploration of mechanisms
underlying species replacement during succession (sensu
Connell & Slatyer 1977). Such analysis is possible if the
abundance and composition of mature plant communities
are mirrored in the characteristics of the seed banks.
There is some evidence indicating that this is true for
woody species (Ceccon et al. 2006, Dalling & Denslow
1998). Three possible patterns can be expected to occur in