Journal of Scientific Research and Development 2 (7): 304-312, 2015
Available online at www.jsrad.org
ISSN 1115-7569
© 2015 JSRAD
304
On the effectiveness of three types of assessment on EFL learners' self-regulation
Abbas Ali Zar ei
1, *
, Zahr a Uselfi
2
1
Associate professor, Imam Khomeini International University, Qazvin
2
MA, Islamic Azad University, Qazvin
Abstract: The present study was conducted to investigate the effects of self, peer, and teacher -assessment on EFL
learners’ self-regulation. The participants were 94 male and female Iranian EFL learners at IT English language
institute in Qazvin. The instruments included a 55-item Preliminary English Test (PET) and the Persian translation
of a 32-item self-regulation questionnaire. The participants were randomly assigned to three groups, and each
group received one of the treatment conditions (self, peer, and teacher -assessment). They were also given the
questionnaire twice, once before the treatment and once after it. The collected data were analyzed using the
ANCOVA procedure. The results of the study showed no significant differences among the effects of the three types
of assessment on self-regulation. The findings of this study may have theoretical and pedagogical implications for
learners, teachers and syllabus designers.
Key words: Self- assessment; Peer - assessment; Teacher -assessment; Self-regulation
1. Introduction
*
Among learners’ personality traits, self-efficacy
beliefs have received considerable attention
(Bandura, 1986 - 1989; Pintrich and Schunk, 1995;
Zimmerman, 2000). According to Zimmerman
(2000), Albert Bandura, a cognitive psychologist, in
1977, introduced self-efficacy for the first time and
viewed it as individuals’ beliefs of their own
competence to do an activity. Over the past few
decades, there has been a major shift from teacher-
centered learning strategy use to learner-centered
learning strategy use in EFL educational systems
(Reiss, 1985; Tamada, 1996).
A number of researchers have investigated the
relationship between self-efficacy components (self-
regulation, goal-orientation, and achievement
motivation) and educational performance. Self-
regulation is a concept that refers to learners’
purposeful and active participation in their own
learning processes. Zimmerman (1986) claims that
self-regulated learners can use their metacognition
purposefully to improve their own motivation in an
active manner in their road to learning. Self-
regulation may be influenced by a number of factors.
One of the factors, which is of interest in the present
study, is the type of assessment.
Assessment has various types including self-
assessment , peer -assessment , and t eacher -
assessment. Boud (1995) refers to self-assessment
as learners’ reflection on their own work and
evaluation of their own performance against the
assigned criteria. Falchikov (1995) refers to peer-
assessment as learners’ reflection on their
*
Corresponding Author.
classmates’ work against the assigned criteria.
Brown and Hudson, (1998) refer to t eacher -
assessment as the traditional and formal system in
which teachers take the responsibility for assessing
students’ performance.
There have been several studies investigating the
effects of different types of self-efficacy such as self-
regulation, goal-orientation, and achievement
motivation on learners’ performance (Bandura et al.,
1996; 2001; McCarthy et al., 1985; Zimmerman et
al., 1992), and the effects of self (Brown, 2005;
Butler and Lee, 2010; Chen, 2008, Falchikov and
Boud, 1989; Leach, 2012), peer (Cheng and Warren,
2005; Falchikov, 1995; Freeman, 1995), and teacher-
assessment (Chacon, 2005; Hoy and Davis, 2006) on
learners’ performance. However, few studies have
specifically investigated the relationship between
self-regulation as psychological factor and different
types of assessment (self, peer , and t eacher -
assessment) (Alfallay, 2004; Nicol and Macfarlane-
Dick, 2006).Thus, the main focus of the present study
is on investigating the effects of self, peer, and
teacher-assessment on Iranian EFL Learners’ self-
regulation. More specifically, this study aims to find
answer for the following research question:
Are there any significant differences among the
effects of self, peer, and teacher assessment on
Iranian EFL learners’ self-regulation?
2. Literature review
2.1. Self-regulation
Zimmerman and Bandura (1994) state that self-
regulation refers to learners’ mind generating
concepts which assist them in their feelings and