Comparison of transmission losses and voltage drops of
GIL(Gas Insulated transmission line ) and overhead
transmission lines
Danish Khan, Muhammad Rafiq, Syed Furqan Rafique, Idris Khan and Farukh Abbas
North China Electric Power University
Beijing, China
danishjadoon90@gmail.com
Abstract—In a power system the loads are connected to the
generation plants through transmission lines. The transmission
lines are overhead and underground cables. From last forty years
the new technology is included in the underground cable GIL.
GIL has lot of advantages on underground cables and overhead
transmission lines such as low transmission losses, less capacitive
load, reliability, personal safety , same operation as overhead
lines and with negligible electric aging. GIL can handle much
more power than overhead lines due to his large conductor area.
GIL is best for high voltages.GIL can be our future lines specially
in big cities due to increasing population and size of big cities. In
this paper the losses and voltage drops of same voltage rated
overhead lines are compared to GIL lines. The simulation in
PSCAD is done using the parameters of overhead and GIL lines
of same rated voltages (230 KV, 345KV, 500KV, 765KV,1100KV)
. The length of line is taken as 100km in both cases. The
comparison graphs of percentage losses and voltage drops are
plotted using MATLAB.
Keywords—GIL(Gas Insulated transmission line), OHL(over
head lines)
I. INTRODUCTION
GIL is best option for high voltages due to high power
rating. Due to large area it can pass lot of current than
overhead lines. The area is inversely proportional to the
resistance. In this way the resistance of GIL is much more
lower than overhead lines. The diameter of 500KV GIL is at
about 500mm, and 1100KV GIL has diameter at about
760mm[1]. On the other hand in overhead line the kiwi code
conductor with four layers has diameter at about 17.37mm
and falcon with three layers has 15.91mm[2]. GIL power
rating is much higher than overhead lines.The transmission
losses of GIL are much lower than overhead transmission
lines. To build a high voltage line is a difficult task due to
public obstacles and Right of way. In future GIL lines can be
installed over the long distances. The GIL in Japan is 3.25km
is the longest GIL line[3]. Due to high installation cost GIL
is not used over the long distances.
II. CALCULATION OF LOSSES
A. Calculation of overhead transmission line losses
Simulation is done in PSCAD. Three phase circuit is taken
having power measurements on both sides. The parameters are
taken from below table 1.
TABLE I. PARAMETERS OF OVERHEAD TRANSMISSION LINES
Voltages
level
Line parameters per km
Resistance per km Inductance per km
Susceptance per
km
230kv 0.050 0.488 3.371
345kv 0.037 0.367 4.518
500kv 0.028 0.325 5.2
765kv 0.012 0.329 4.978
1100kv 0.005 0.292 5.544
The voltage source, line parameters and load are
simulated. The capacitors are connected on both sides because
transmission line is taken as medium 100km line.The
multimeters are connected for measuring power at sending end
and receiving end.The parameters for 100km lines are taken
for each of voltage levels.The result obtained from the
simulation are following.
16th International Power Electronics and Motion Control Conference and Exposition Antalya, Turkey 21-24 Sept 2014
PEMC 2014 1151
978-1-4799-2060-0/14/$31.00 ©2014 IEEE