Geography Compass 9/5 (2015): 225–236, 10.1111/gec3.12212
Seeds, Agricultural Systems and Socio-natures: Towards an
Actor–Network Theory Informed Political Ecology of
Agriculture
Natasha Watts
1
and Ivan R. Scales
2
*
1
Department of Geography, University of Cambridge
2
St Catharine’s College, University of Cambridge
Abstract
Agriculture has recently been the subject of considerable research and policy attention. Events such as the
2008 ‘world food price crisis’ and concerns over the future of global food security have led to calls for a
‘New Green Revolution’, with an emphasis on boosting yields through new transgenic crop varieties.
However, critics have raised concerns over the growing role of global agribusiness and transnational
capital in agriculture, as well as the potential social and ecological impacts of new technologies. An analysis
of emerging agricultural trends thus demands a framework that is able to negotiate the complex
multi-scalar interplay between environmental, technological, scientific, political and economic factors.
In this paper, we focus on the potential contribution of a synthesis between political ecology and Actor–
Network Theory to our understanding of agricultural networks. We review the literature with a view to
teasing out key insights and sketching out future research priorities. We focus on questions surrounding
power and agency, the political ecology of scale and the role of situated knowledges and practices.
Introduction
Agriculture has been the subject of considerable research and policy attention over the last
10 years. Events such as the 2008 ‘world food price crisis’ have raised questions about the ability
of global food production to meet growing demand (e.g. FAO 2008; Foresight 2011; World
Bank 2008). There have been calls for a ‘New Green Revolution’ to develop new crop varieties
to increase global food productivity, improve nutrition and help farmers cope with climate
change (Godfray et al. 2010; Rockefeller 2006). Such developments follow more than a century
of agricultural innovation and intensification, culminating in the agro-industrial model of
production. At the same time, critics have raised concerns about the growing role of global
agribusiness, the social and ecological impacts of new technologies (including genetically
modified organisms – GMOs), the implications of trade liberalisation for farmers and the role
of the financialisation of agricultural commodities in food price instability (Bernstein 2014;
McMichael 2009).
These trends point to the complex socio-environmental interactions that shape agriculture.
An analysis of agricultural trends thus demands a framework that is able to negotiate the
multi-scalar interplay between environmental, technological, scientific, political and economic
factors. In this paper, we look at the potential contribution to our understanding of agricultural
networks of a synthesis between political ecology (PE) and ideas from Science and Technology
Studies (STS), more specifically Actor–Network Theory (ANT).
From its emergence in the 1980s, PE has concerned itself with providing place-based
understandings of the factors that shape human–environment interactions, with agriculture
© 2015 The Author(s)
Geography Compass © 2015 John Wiley & Sons Ltd