Cheap C18-modified Silica Monolith Particles as HPLC Stationary Phase
of Good Separation Efficiency
Ashraf Ali, Faiz Ali, and Won Jo Cheong
*
Department of Chemistry, Inha University, Incheon 402-751, South Korea. *E-mail: wjcheong@inha.ac.kr
Received January 19, 2015, Accepted February 23, 2015, Published online May 26, 2015
Keywords: Silica monolith particles, C18 modification, Partially sub-2 μm, High separation efficiency
Columns packed with silica-based bonded phases have
been used in reversed-phase liquid chromatography because
of their high porosity, large surface area, compatibility with dif-
ferent solvents, mechanical stability, ease of surface modifica-
tion, and economic feasibility. Bulk monolithic columns have
attracted a considerable amount of interest in the last decade,
and both monolithic and packed chromatographic columns have
their own advantages and disadvantages.
1–5
The columns
packed with particles have a high efficiency but they are accom-
panied with a high column back pressure due to lower permea-
bility, while the monolithic columns have a high permeability
but they result in inferior separation efficiency for the analysis
of small molecules in HPLC.
6–13
In our laboratory, we have been
using the pseudo-monolithic silica particles with C-18
ligand
1,14,15
or polystyrene film
1,2,16–18
as packing materials.
In the current study, porous partially sub-2 μm silica monolith
particles have been prepared by a sol–gel process with a six times
increased production scale compared with our previous
work.
16,17
These particles have been chemically modified with
a C18 reagent and end-capped with a mixture of trimethylchlor-
osilane (TMCS) and 1,1,1,3,3,3 hexamethyldisilazane (HMDS)
and packed in HPLC columns (1.0 mm × 300 mm). Five ana-
lytes (phenol, acetophenone, 4-methyl-2-nitroaniline, benzene,
and toluene) are separated with good separation efficiency
and resolution by using 60/40 (v/v) ACN/ H
2
O containing
0.1% TFA as the mobile phase with a flow rate of 25 μL/min.
In our another previous study,
15
C18-modified partially
sub-1 μm silica monolith particles were prepared and packed
in a column of 15 cm length to show excellent separation effi-
ciency with the number of theoretical plates (N) of about
180,000/m. Nevertheless, the N value per column was only
27,000 since the maximum length of the packed column
was only 15 cm due to the reduced particle size. In this study,
C18-modified partially sub-2 μm silica monolith particles
have been prepared in an enhanced production scale and suc-
cessfully packed in columns of 30 cm length to show the
enhanced N value per column (37,000) although the
N value per meter has been reduced to 123,000/m.
Characterization of Bare and C18-modified Silica
Monolith Particles
Figure 1 shows the microscopic view (a) and SEM images of
C18-bound silica monolith particles (b, c, d) of this study. The
surface of C18-bound silica monolith particles is rather rough
as shown in Figure 1(d), in comparison to the polystyrene-
bound silica monolith particles of our previous studies.
16,17
This is natural because the C18 moiety is attached in the form
of single alkyl chain and the roughness of the silica surface is
almost maintained.
A promising result was observed in the particle size distri-
bution of silica monolith particles prepared in an enhanced
production scale of this study (Table 1 and Figure 2) com-
pared with that of the production of a smaller scale.
17
Both
the d(0.5) value (average particle size) and the dispersity of
distribution of this study were reduced considerably in com-
parison to the results of the previous study,
17
which will be
beneficial in view of mass transfer kinetics and separation
efficiency.
The BET/BJH N
2
adsorption/desorption plots for bare silica
and C18-bound silica particles are shown in Figure 3. The
BET/BJH adsorption–desorption reports of the previous and
current studies are comparatively summarized in Table 2.
The pore size was decreased from 296 Å for bare silica
to 216 Å for C18-bound silica monolith particles after modi-
fication as shown in Figure 3 and Table 2. The decrease in
pore size after C18 modification is relatively greater in the cur-
rent study. Some differences were again observed in the prop-
erties of bare silica monolith particles between the batch of
this study prepared on a larger scale and the batch of the pre-
vious study
17
prepared on a smaller scale. The pore size, total
pore volume, and surface area of current study were all some-
what reduced in comparison to those of the previous study
(Table 2).
Chromatographic Performances
It seems that the minor changes of physical properties of
the silica monolith particles induced by the scale-up did not
cause any trouble in separation performance of the resultant
stationary phase of this study since the chromatographic per-
formance of the column packed with the stationary phase
of this study has proven to be better than those of a 5 μm com-
mercial C18 phase or the C18-modified silica monolith parti-
cles of the previous study as shown in Figure 4, and the column
theoretical plates of this study (average 37,700) were found
rather in the level of the top class HPLC columns as shown
in Table 3.
Note
DOI: 10.1002/bkcs.10320 A. Ali et al.
BULLETIN OF THE
KOREAN CHEMICAL SOCIETY
Bull. Korean Chem. Soc. 2015, Vol. 36, 1733–1736 © 2015 Korean Chemical Society, Seoul & Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim Wiley Online Library 1733