2011 International Conference on Electrical Engineering and Informatics
17-19 July 2011, Bandung, Indonesia
A Novel Power Swing Detection Algorithm Using
Adaptive Neuro Fuzzy Technique
Ahad Esmaeilian, Sajjad Astinfeshan
School of Electrical and Computer Engineering, University of Tehran, Iran
a.esmaeilian@ece.ut.ac.ir
Abstract— Any sudden change in the configuration or the loading
of an electrical network causes power swing between the load
concentrations of the network. Power swing can affect the
distance relay performance by entering the impedance locus into
protection zone of the relay causing unnecessary tripping. In this
paper a novel technique to prevent the distance relay from
tripping during power swing is presented. The presented method
is based on adaptive neuro-fuzzy inference system (ANFIS)
which has three inputs, include the rate of change of positive
sequence current, active and reactive powers. Adaptive neuro
fuzzy method is implemented utilizing MATLAB/ANFIS toolbox.
For the purpose of testing a typical power network which is used
in previous works is modelled in PSCAD software, a data set
consisting of more than 2500 different power swing scenarios is
also considered to guarantee the results are accurate in different
conditions.
Keywords— Power swing detection, Distance relay, Adaptive
Neuro Fuzzy Inference System (ANFIS).
I. INTRODUCTION
Power systems under steady state conditions operate
typically close to their nominal frequency. A balance between
generated and consumed active power exists during steady
state operating conditions. One of the most important reasons
that lead to the power grid blackout is the power swing. Power
system faults, line switching, generator disconnection, and the
loss or application of large blocks of load result in sudden
changes to electrical power, whereas the mechanical power
input to generators remains relatively constant. These system
disturbances cause oscillations in machine rotor angles and
can result in severe power flow swings [1].
During power swings because of variation of rotor angles,
the angle between two areas of the power system fluctuates. If
the swing is stable, the fluctuations die down [2]. However,
unstable swings result in progressive separation of angle
between two areas of the power system, causing large swings
of power, large fluctuations of voltages and currents and
eventual loss of synchronism between such areas [2]. If two
areas are in phase, the voltages will become the maximum
value and the currents will inversely become minimum, while
in the out of phase areas (by 180°), currents and voltages will
be at their peak value and close to zero respectively. Since the
system frequency is a function of rotor speed, the frequency of
voltages and currents during power swings is not constant.
The frequency of occurrence of voltage/current maximum
depends on the rate of change of the power angle between the
two areas and is characterized by a ‘slip’ frequency. The slip
frequency can be as low as 1–3 Hz (slow swing) and as high
as 4–7 Hz (fast swing) [3].
Many techniques have been introduced to block the trip
signal during power swing. In [2], Brahma utilized wavelet
transform to identify power swing. However the proposed
method is able to detect the symmetrical faults during power
swing, its sampling rate is more than 40 kHz which cause the
method to be expensive for the purpose of implementation.
In [4] author compares some reported methods and
concludes that tracking of apparent resistance gives better
performance, since it changes during power swings but does
not change during the period when a symmetrical fault exists.
Ref. [5] applies a simple approach which is based on DC
component of current achieved from FFT analysis to detect a
fault quickly and reliably during a power swing. However,
further testing is needed in larger power systems before the
existing technique can be deployed to a distance relay.
In [6], a method is based on the extraction of the current
waveform components using the Prony method is introduced.
While the method is accurate for detection of symmetrical
faults from power swing, it is neglected to report the PSB
output in the case of high resistance single phase faults.
In [7] the authors present a new blocking method during
fast swings based on load angle differences identification.
While the method is accurate for both slow and fast swings,
the authors did not consider the symmetrical fault in their case
studies.
In this paper, an adaptive neuro fuzzy approach is used to
detect power swings and a very accurate PSB scheme is
designed.
The proposed ANFIS scheme has three inputs, include the
rate of change of positive sequence current, active power and
reactive power. Since power swings are characterized by slow
variation currents, it is very typical to use the rate of change of
currents as an input to ANFIS network. On the other hand, the
maximum between normalized |dP/dt| and |dQ/dt| is always
equal or greater than 0.7 during power swing. However, they
will level off to 0 when a three phase fault occurs during
power swings. Use of these two inputs is also seemed to be
E15 - 5
978-1-4577-0752-0/11/$26.00 ©2011 IEEE