XIX IMEKO World Congress
Fundamental and Applied Metrology
September 6!11, 2009, Lisbon, Portugal
BASIC CHARACTERISTICS OF ZIGBEE AND SIMPLICITI MODULES
TO USE IN MEASUREMENT SYSTEMS
L. Skrzypczak
1 )
, D. Grimaldi
2)
, R. Rak
3)
1)
Department of Electronics, Computer and System Sciences, University of Calabria, Rende – CS, Italy,
slk@data.pl
2)
Department of Electronics, Computer and System Sciences, University of Calabria, Rende – CS, Italy,
grimaldi@deis.unical.it
3)
Institute of the Theory of Electrical Engineering, Information and Measurement Systems,
Electrical Engineering Faculty, Warsaw University of Technology, Warsaw, Poland, rrak@okno.pw.edu.pl
Abstract – The main goal of this paper is to
experimental examine some of the properties of two
different wireless communication modules, ZigBee and
SimpliciTI, which are employing two different transmission
standards. This paper is a part of wider research aimed to
examine and evaluate the different wireless transmission
standards to use in distributed measurement systems.
Keywords : ZigBee; SimpliciTI; Distributed
Measurement Systems
1. INTRODUCTION
The use of new wireless transmission standards in
measurement systems is described by some requirements of
industrial applications such those presented in [1] which are
(i) integration into existing measurement systems, (ii)
coordination of the advanced and traditional monitoring
structures, and (iii) design of innovative measurement
systems. This paper is an attempt to examine two different
wireless transmission standards named ZigBee and
SimpliciTI in order to meet those requirements.
SimpliciTI is Texas Instruments proprietary network
protocol [2] for low-power radio frequency wireless
communication. Main properties of SimpliciTI are [2]:
Low cost which means that SimpliciTI network protocol can
be implemented in systems with small memory capacity.
According to [2] as low as 8 kB of ROM and 1 kB of RAM
is needed to implement SimpliciTI.
Flexibility which is achieved by multiple network topologies
namely star and peer-to-per (p2p) [2].
The basic Application Programmers Interface (API) makes
SimpliciTI simple to be used.
Wide selection of transceiver chips made to work with
SimpliciTI operating in sub-1GHz frequencies and in 2.4
GHz band [3] makes this protocol versatile.
Finally very low current consumption in sleep state [2]
makes SimpliciTI very well suited for battery powered
applications.
ZigBee is wireless communication standard managed by
the ZigBee Alliance and is based on the standard IEEE
802.15.4 physical and Media Access Control (MAC) layers
[4].
Main properties of ZigBee are [5]:
Flexible network topology. Simple star topology as well as
more complicated mesh topology are possible. This makes
ZigBee easy to install because when using mesh topology
network range is not limited to maximum range of the single
device.
ZigBee scalability is also achieved by static and dynamic
star and mesh topology allowing mode than 65000 nodes
with low latency to be connected to the same network [5].
Low power is achieved by allowing long periods of non-
communication without the need for re-synchronisation [5].
Because ZigBee Alliance is not limited to one company
many manufacturers produce ZigBee modules and
equipment such antennas. This makes competition on the
market which means low prices.
The cause of choosing these two transmission standards
is that they were designed for monitoring and control
applications [5], [2]. Such applications are closely related to
measurement systems field.
This paper is a presentation of characteristics of both
standards in the area of measurement systems.
The following sections describe the measured
parameters, the methodology of making presented
measurements, used wireless modules and environmental
conditions under which all presented measurements were
made.
At the end the conclusion is made on the basis of
experimental results.
2. RESEARCH OVERVIEW
Characteristics of tested modules is based on Quality of
Service (QoS) parameters. These parameters derived from
[6] are listed in Table 1.
1456 ISBN 978-963-88410-0-1 © 2009 IMEKO