African Journal of AIDS Research 2009, 8(1): 17–27
Printed in South Africa — All rights reserved
Copyright © NISC Pty Ltd
AJAR
ISSN 1608–5906 EISSN 1727–9445
doi: 10.2989/AJAR.2009.8.1.3.716
Introduction
In the era of HIV and AIDS the human body has assumed
a multifaceted status in social discourse. Viewed on one
hand as an object of medical gaze which requires closer
observation to obtain information about the activity of the
virus (through indicators such as CD4 cell count and viral
load) and information about the epidemic through surveil-
lances, and viewed on the other hand as an object that can
evoke fear of the risk of HIV infection through contact with
bodily fluids, and as something to be avoided, especially if
the patient is an individual that matches certain predomi-
nant stereotypes about population groups and communities
perceived to be at high risk of HIV infection.
The imagery of the body permeates all aspects of life
in contemporary societies; the overarching values are the
‘attractiveness,’ ‘fitness’ and ‘healthiness’ of the body. An
unprecedented focus on the body renders the management
of HIV-related illnesses a matter of concern, which both lay
people and professionals in various disciplines (especially
nutrition and dermatology and physicians) attempt to
address with rigour.
In Lesotho, a resource-poor country with HIV/AIDS
prevalence that is among the highest in the world, the
unavailability of ARVs in public hospitals prior to 2004
reduced the capacity of hospitals to admit patients with
chronic HIV-related illnesses. Kimaryo, Okpaku, Githuku-
Shongwe & Feeney (2003, p. 69) note that due to “the lack
of basic medicine and qualified personnel, health facili-
ties are struggling to cope with the provision of appropriate
treatment and care.” As in other countries in sub-Saharan
Africa that situation led to a shift to home-based care
(Bindura-Mutangadura, 2000; Akintola, 2006) with
home-based care being identified in official documents
as an important strategy for responding to HIV and AIDS
(Lesotho Ministry of Health and Social Welfare & World
Health Organization [WHO], 2002). Undoubtedly, these
constraints and changes regarding the locus of care for
chronically ill AIDS patients has increased the prominence
of the body in caregiving situations, but the ways in which
family caregivers experience patients’ bodies has received
little attention in Lesotho.
The long-term socio-economic consequences of AIDS
illness on family wellbeing, the resourcefulness of informal
networks in the provision of care, and the burden of care
have all been studied. Studies in sub-Saharan Africa indicate
that family members experience stress and financial burden
as a result of caring for relatives with HIV-related illnesses
(Ankrah, 1993; Bindura-Mutangadura, 2000; Baylies, 2002).
Seeley, Kajura, Bachengana, Okongo, Wagner & Mulder
(1993) argued that as a result of protracted AIDS illness,
household resources are eroded and families are burdened
as their capacity to provide care is gradually diminished. In
most instances family caregivers lack the essential skills,
knowledge and emotional support, thus rendering caregiving
extremely challenging (Uys, 2003). This occurs because, by
The phenomenology of bodily care: caregivers’ experiences with AIDS
patients before antiretroviral therapies in Lesotho
Mokhantšo G Makoae
Human Sciences Research Council, Plein Park Building, 12th Floor, 69-83 Plein Street, Cape Town 8000, South Africa
Author’s e-mail: mmakoae@hsrc.ac.za
This study provides an account of caregivers’ experiences with the bodily care of AIDS patients before antiretroviral
therapies were available in the public health sector in Lesotho. It describes the mechanisms through which the body
may become a stressor in caregiving. The phenomenological method, guided by the notion of epoché, was used to
understand caregiving experiences from the perspective of family caregivers. Data on caregivers’ physical activities
and what they saw and thought were collected through in-depth interviews with 21 caregivers (mostly females);
the caregivers were identified with the help of HIV/AIDS counsellors at two hospitals where AIDS patients received
medical treatment. The thematic analysis shows that a patient’s body was central in caregiving experiences. Social
interaction in caregiving was mediated through seeing and touching the bodies of the patients. The different
aspects of caregiving and the close interaction with the body of an ill family member — especially seeing major
changes in the patient’s physical appearance, their declined capacity to perform the activities of daily living, and
discovering the symptoms of their illness — contributed to the caregivers’ experiences of sympathy and pain. The
social meanings and boundaries that tended to persist regarding touching and accessing others’ bodies and bodily
matter also contributed to the caregivers’ stress.
Keywords: caregiving, chronic illness, HIV/AIDS, home-based care, phenomenological epoché, psychological aspects,
social discourse, southern Africa, stress