ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Risk Factors for Alzheimer Disease: A Population-Based
Case-Control Study in Istanbul, Turkey
Hande Harmanci, MD, Murat Emre, MD, Hakan Gurvit, MD, Basar Bilgic, MD, Hasmet Hanagasi, MD,
Edip Gurol, MD, Huseyin Sahin, MD, and Sule Tinaz, MD
Summary: The objective is to study risk factors for Alzheimer dis-
ease (AD) in Istanbul, Turkey. This is a population-based case-
control study. We screened people over age 70 in the community for
cognitive impairment. The screen positives and a proportion of screen
negatives underwent neurologic examination in the second phase.
Cases were 57 “probable” AD patients and controls were 127 cogni-
tively normal individuals identified by neurologic examination. Odds
ratios (OR) were calculated using multivariate logistic regression
analysis. Having a university/college degree had a protective effect on
AD risk (OR = 0.10, 95% confidence interval [CI] = 0.02–0.50). Ex-
posure to occupational electromagnetic field had an OR of 4.02 (95%
CI = 1.02–15.78). Use of electricity for residential heating also
showed elevated risk (OR = 2.77, 95% CI = 1.12–6.85). Our results
suggest that having a higher education is protective from AD and that
electromagnetic field exposure at work or at home is a significant risk
factor.
Key Words: risk factors, education, electromagnetic field, EMF,
Turkey
(Alzheimer Dis Assoc Disord 2003;17:139–145)
A
lzheimer disease (AD) is becoming a major public health
problem as populations age and the proportion of the aged
constitute a growing proportion of the population. The high
prevalence
1–3
and incidence rates,
4–5
combined with the social
and economic burden, rank AD high in the list of important
health problems of the modern society.
A steady stream of studies has been published for the risk
factors of AD for the last two decades. A review article
6
groups
these studies into four types: those that have examined familial
and genetic factors (gender, family history, APOE, etc),
clinical/illness-related risk factors (Down syndrome, thyroid
disease, head injury, etc), exposure to environmental hazards
(estrogen replacement therapy, nonsteroidal anti inflammatory
drugs [NSAIDs], tobacco, alcohol, electromagnetic fields
(EMFs), aluminum, etc.), and sociodemographic characteris-
tics (education, occupation, rural area of residence, household
characteristics, etc) as risk factors. Among those, only age and
positive family history are considered as definite risk factors.
Most of the publications on AD have come from the de-
veloped world. Developing countries have not been able to re-
port reliable data on dementias and AD, possibly because they
have less resources for research and health services for the care
of the elderly. The Indo-U.S. study
7
is one of the few from a
developing country, and it reports lower prevalence figures
compared with developed nations, with possible explanations
of low overall life expectancy, short survival with the disease,
and low age-specific incidence potentially due to differences
in the underlying distribution of risk and protective factors
compared with populations with higher prevalence. One pro-
spective study
8
examines incidence rate differences between
Nigerians and African Americans living in Illinois and reports
significant differences between the two populations with Ni-
gerians having lower incidence rates.
We here present the first AD risk factor study from Tur-
key as part of the Turkish Alzheimer Prevalence Study.
METHODS
This study was carried out in Kadikoy, Istanbul, Turkey.
The sample for the cross-sectional part of this study was deter-
mined as 1067 individuals 70 years of age or older randomly
selected from population registries (records of the muhtars’
1
list). After obtaining addresses from muhtars, all subjects were
visited in their homes by a group of trained interviewers. Those
who were not found at home were visited two more times. As-
suming a community prevalence of 50%, we determined that
Received for publication August 7, 2002; accepted March 8, 2003.
From the Department of Public Health (Dr Harmanci), Marmara University
Medical Faculty, and the Department of Neurology (Drs Emre, Gurvit,
Bilgic, Hanagasi, Gurol, Sahin, and Tinaz), Istanbul University, Istanbul
Medical Faculty, Istanbul, Turkey.
This project was supported by a non-restricted research grant from Novartis
A.S Turkey.
Reprints: Dr. Hande Harmanci, Marmara University Medical Faculty, Depart-
ment of Public Health, Haydarpasa 81326, Istanbul, Turkey (e-mail:
hharmanci@marmara.edu.tr).
Copyright © 2003 by Lippincott Williams & Wilkins
1
A muhtar is an elected official responsible mainly of keeping records of the
population living in a defined geographical area. The records contain the
following information: name, address, date and place of birth, mother’s
and father’s names.
Alzheimer Dis Assoc Disord • Volume 17, Number 3, July–September 2003 139