International Journal of Gynecology and Obstetrics 118, Supplement 2 (2012) S113–S120
CONSEQUENCES OF UNSAFE ABORTION ON MORBIDITY AND MORTALITY
Pathways and consequences of unsafe abortion: A comparison among women with
complications after induced and spontaneous abortions in Madhya Pradesh, India
Sushanta K. Banerjee
a,
*, Kathryn L. Andersen
b
, Janardan Warvadekar
a
a
Ipas India, New Delhi, India
b
Ipas, Chapel Hill, NC, USA
ARTICLE INFO ABSTRACT
Keywords:
India
Induced abortion
Postabortion complications
Spontaneous abortion
This study aimed to understand women’s pathways of seeking care for postabortion complications in Mad-
hya Pradesh, India. The study recruited 786 women between July and November 2007. Data were collected
on service provision, abortion-related complications, care-seeking behavior, knowledge about abortion legal-
ity and availability, methods used, symptoms, referral source, and out-of-pocket costs. Women seeking care
for complications from induced abortion followed more complex pathways to treatment than women with
complications of spontaneous abortion. More complex pathways were associated with higher out-of-pocket
costs. Improving community awareness on legal aspects, safe abortion methods, and trained providers are
necessary to reduce morbidity associated with unsafe abortion.
© 2012 Published by Elsevier Ireland Ltd. on behalf of International Federation of Gynecology and Obstetrics.
1. Introduction
In 1971, the Indian parliament passed the Medical Termination
of Pregnancy Act (MTP Act) enabling women to seek abortion
across a range of situations: when the mother’s life is at risk or
when her physical and mental health are compromised, or if the
pregnancy is the result of rape or contraceptive failure, or is likely
to result in fetal impairment. Unfortunately, this relatively liberal
law has not led to significant reduction in unsafe abortion. Of 6.4
million induced abortions performed in India, 3.6 million (56%) are
unsafe [1]. Complications of spontaneous abortion also contribute
to maternal morbidity; an estimated 5% of pregnancies in India
end in spontaneous abortion [2]. In all, there are approximately
10 000 to 12 000 deaths in India each year due to abortion-related
complications [3].
In Madhya Pradesh, one of India’s largest states, safe abortion
services are often not available at primary health centers, which
serve as the first contact point for the largely rural population
of 51 million. Only 3% of primary health centers and 19% of
community health centers provide induced abortion services [4].
Stigma, lack of knowledge about safe services, and a paucity of
accessible and trained providers often lead women to seek care
from more convenient but unskilled providers who use unsafe
abortion methods. This may have consequences as the likelihood
of experiencing postabortion complications depends on the training
and skill of the abortion provider, procedure used, and conditions
under which the procedure is performed.
* Corresponding author: Sushanta K. Banerjee, E-63 Vasant Marg, Vasant Vihar,
New Delhi 110057, India. Tel.: +91 11 4606 8811.
E-mail address: banerjees@ipas.org (S.K. Banerjee).
0020-7292/$ – see front matter © 2012 Published by Elsevier Ireland Ltd. on behalf of International Federation of Gynecology and Obstetrics.
In India, few studies have examined the causal routes of
postabortion complications, particularly by unqualified providers.
A quantitative study of induced abortion in rural Bangladesh (a
country with similar demographic characteristics) found that even
when trained service providers are available, women often seek
services from untrained providers and use clandestine methods
that lead to increased morbidity, health service use, and cost
[5]. No studies describing care-seeking behavior for spontaneous
abortion complications were identified. Detailed information about
common clandestine abortion methods used, types and severity of
complications, and perceived symptoms or signs of complications
has not been available for women in India.
The purpose of the present study was to compare women
with induced abortions with women with spontaneous abortions
using the following factors: (1) types and symptoms of postabor-
tion complications; (2) social and demographic characteristics and
reproductive health history; (3) pathways of seeking services
and treatment for abortion and postabortion complications; (4)
type/profile of providers who offered abortion and postabortion
services and treatment and management of postabortion complica-
tions; and (5) consequences of postabortion complications in terms
of symptom severity and cost.
2. Data and methods
Women presenting to hospitals in 6 districts in Madhya Pradesh
with postabortion complications were recruited prospectively. Five
government-run medical college hospitals and 5 district hospitals
were purposively selected as study sites because of their anticipated
high caseload of abortion complications, geographic representation
across the state, and institutional capacity for participation in