Field-Flow Fractionation and Hydrodynamic Chromatography on a
Microfluidic Chip
Tyler N. Shendruk,
‡
Radin Tahvildari,
‡
Nicolas M. Catafard, Lukasz Andrzejewski, Christian Gigault,
Andrew Todd, Laurent Gagne-Dumais, Gary W. Slater, and Michel Godin*
Department of Physics, University of Ottawa, MacDonald Hall, K1N 6N5 Ottawa, Canada
ABSTRACT: We present gravitational field-flow fractionation and hydrodynamic
chromatography of colloids eluting through 18 μm microchannels. Using video
microscopy and mesoscopic simulations, we investigate the average retention ratio of
colloids with both a large specific weight and neutral buoyancy. We consider the entire
range of colloid sizes, including particles that barely fit in the microchannel and
nanoscopic particles. Ideal theory predicts four operational modes, from hydrodynamic
chromatography to Faxe ́ n-mode field-flow fractionation. We experimentally demonstrate,
for the first time, the existence of the Faxe ́ n-mode field-flow fractionation and the
transition from hydrodynamic chromatography to normal-mode field-flow fractionation.
Furthermore, video microscopy and simulations show that the retention ratios are largely
reduced above the steric-inversion point, causing the variation of the retention ratio in the
steric- and Faxe ́ n-mode regimes to be suppressed due to increased drag. We demonstrate
that theory can accurately predict retention ratios if hydrodynamic interactions with the
microchannel walls (wall drag) are added to the ideal theory. Rather than limiting the applicability, these effects allow the
microfluidic channel size to be tuned to ensure high selectivity. Our findings indicate that particle velocimetry methods must
account for the wall-induced lag when determining flow rates in highly confining systems.
F
ield-flow fractionation (FFF),
1,2
a broad class of separation
techniques, is achieved by imposing a transverse force f
across a channel of height h to a solution of solutes such as
colloids,
3
macromolecules,
4
or cells.
5
A concentration gradient
is established in response to the competition between the
thermal energy, k
B
T, and the potential energy drop across the
channel, fh. The system can thus be described in terms of the
dimensionless retention parameter, λ = k
B
T/fh. This solute
distribution is carried through a channel by a Poiseuille flow
with a characteristic retention ratio (average colloid velocity
normalized by average fluid velocity, R = ⟨=⟩/⟨v⟩). Colloids of
different sizes r have different concentration distributions and
therefore different retention ratios, R.
This simple system possesses surprisingly rich elution
behavior. Previously, we considered the ideal retention theory
(ignoring complications such as nonparabolic flow,
6
nondilute
concentration effects,
7
slip,
8
or hydrodynamic/lift interac-
tions
9
), and predicted the existence of four distinct operational
modes.
10
The transitions between them were mapped;
however, only three of the four modes and only a single
transition had ever been previously observed experimentally.
For large λ, thermal energy dominates and solutes diffuse
across the entire channel. Only steric interactions with the walls
limit their distribution, as shown in Figure 1. This is the
hydrodynamic chromatography limit of FFF (HC),
11
where
larger particles elute before smaller particles. Ideally, density-
matched tracer particles used for micro-particle image
velocimetry
12
elute in HC, in the absence of any net external
body forces.
If the potential energy dominates over the thermal energy,
the concentration profile across the channel height becomes
exponential. In this normal-mode field-flow fractionation
(nFFF), ensembles of small solutes can loosely be thought of
as point particles subject to an external force that increases with
particle size r (nFFF in Figure 1). Therefore, larger particles
stay close to the accumulation wall where the lower flow
velocity causes them to move more slowly than smaller
particles.
1
Experimental observation of the transition between
HC and nFFF has not previously been reported.
However, nFFF can only continue to exist for a certain size
range before the size dependence changes once again. Larger
(heavier) particles are pushed against the wall and steric
interactions exclude the particles from sampling the slow
Received: March 17, 2013
Accepted: May 7, 2013
Published: May 7, 2013
Figure 1. Schematic of ideal field-flow fractionation operational
modes.
Article
pubs.acs.org/ac
© 2013 American Chemical Society 5981 dx.doi.org/10.1021/ac400802g | Anal. Chem. 2013, 85, 5981−5988