2
nd
International Conference “From Scientific Computing to Computational Engineering”
2
nd
IC-SCCE
Athens, 5-8 July, 2006
© IC-SCCE
A SPREADSHEET BASED BUDGETING OF PUBLIC CONSTRUCTION
PROJECTS
Georgios N. Aretoulis
1
, Georgios Papadakis
2
, Glykeria P. Kalfakakou
1
, Demos C. Angelides
1
1
Department of Civil Engineering
Aristotle University of Thessaloniki
Thessaloniki, 54124, Greece
e-mail: garet@civil.auth.gr, web page: http://users.auth.gr/~garet/
2
Overseas Director
ELTER S.A.
Athens, Greece
e-mail: gpapadakis@elter.gr
Keywords: Construction Industry, Cost Estimation, Spreadsheets.
Abstract. The process of competitive bidding in the Greek Construction Industry is of vital importance. Usually
the task of creating project budgets and producing a bidding offer is taking place in an ad hoc manner and a
piecemeal way. That is the main reason why most of the construction projects that span over a long period of
time tend to experience severe cost overruns. It becomes quite obvious that the task of estimating should be
carefully considered. Creating accurate and reliable estimates could potentially lead to a high level of profit for
the project contractor. The prediction of project cost depends on the experience of the cost engineer and the
available means and methods for the necessary estimations. This paper presents firstly the architecture for a
spreadsheet based system which aims at facilitating the task of project cost estimation. This system is
implemented using MS Excel and VBA (Visual Basic for Applications) with a case study. The advantages and
disadvantages of such an approach are discussed and at the same time the required improvements and
performance of the system are analyzed. Finally, future work concerning a proposal for the development of a
more sophisticated and improved approach is presented.
1 INTRODUCTION
There have been significant changes nowadays in the construction industry and its means and practices.
Markets are now more global in character. There has been a significant decline in public sector construction
activity and an increase in the importance of the private client – especially the private corporate client.
Technological change, driven by the rise in the use of information technology (IT), has increased site and off-site
productivity and enabled pre-project modeling of designs with the use of computers. Procurement patterns have
moved away from traditional design – tender – build methods towards design and build and construction
management and partnering methods
[8]
.
However some things have not changed. Fragmentation and confrontation are still endemic in the industry’s
culture and are slow to change in spite of new methods of contract creating cooperative opportunities. Too many
high profile projects still come in late and vastly over budget
[8]
.
It is a fact that in construction project management, time, quality and cost are parameters which require
special attention, due to the unique characteristics of construction industry
[1]
. Variation in project costs usually
results in exceeding the initial estimated cost. In general, projects that span over a long period of time tend to
present time and cost overruns
[2]
. The goal is to achieve construction quality, with minimum time and cost
[3]
. A
traditional system reports the amount of money spent, where and by whom, but fails to provide the cost of
activities and processes
[14]
. Conventional procedures and tools have proved inadequate in providing a structured
decision aid that maximizes the contractor’s chances of winning a job with maximum potential profit
[12]
.
Traditional cost accounting has been criticized for cost distortion and lack of relevance during the last twenty
years
[14]
.