908 Am J Clin Pathol 2015;143:908-911 © American Society for Clinical Pathology
CorrespondenCe
correspondence
908 Am J Clin Pathol 2015;143:908-911 © American Society for Clinical Pathology
Tattoos Containing Useful Messages
Am J Clin Pathol June 2015;143:908-910
DOI: 10.1309/AJCPL32VLCNTMLDV
To the Editor
The article by Carson
1
draws attention to the
association of tattoos with violent death in an autopsy
population. However, as the author correctly points out, age
may be a confounding factor, since tattooing is becoming
an increasingly popular form of body decoration in young
adults. While tattoos may be markers for individuals who
have engaged in criminal activities (eg, tattoos may signify
gang membership, an illegal drug habit, or time spent in
prison), a much wider and more diverse population is now
being inked.
2,3
As such, the potential association of tattoos
with violent deaths would be more clearly delineated by
performing a population-based study of living individuals.
Another point to consider is that although negative and
antisocial messages are often found in tattoos, they may
also contain useful information that may assist during life
with clinical management or after death with identification
or with clarification of particular acts. Tattoos that help
with clinical decision making may document significant
medical conditions such as insulin-dependent diabetes
mellitus, epilepsy or allergies, or blood groups and may
be favored over medic alert bracelets that can be removed
or not worn. On occasion, directions not to perform
cardiopulmonary resuscitation or to take steps to prolong
life may be present. Examples include “DNR” for “do
not resuscitate” and “no PEG” for not having a feeding
gastrostomy tube inserted.
2,3
Unique tattoos that may assist with the identification
of a traumatized, burnt, or decomposed body include
fine-line tattoos of family members or names and dates
commemorating significant events such as births or
marriages. Particular types of tattoos may indicate a country
or region of origin.
4
Rarely, tattoos may include dates of
deaths that were significant and that may match the date of
the decedent’s death. As detailed histories and/or suicide
notes are often not available at the time of a forensic
autopsy, these commemorative tattoos may provide the only
evidence to indicate a possible anniversary suicide.
5
Thus,
although tattoos may be associated with negative outcomes
in an individual’s life, they may also provide very useful
information, both before and after death.
Roger W. Byard, MD
The University of Adelaide Medical School
Adelaide, Australia
References
What Is Hidden in Tattoos?
To the Editor
The article by Carson
1
stimulates several questions.
The differences between the three groups (persons with
no tattoos, those tattooed with nonnegative messages, and
persons tattooed with negative messages) are significant in
age of death. The author concludes that the comparatively
shorter life spans for those with tattoos having negative
messages may be explained by more frequent deaths from
nonnatural causes in this group. Including illicit drugs and
alcohol use contributed. However, the difference between
those with tattoos without negative content and those
having no tattoos must be understood from other aspects.
We propose that the biochemical, toxic, and immunologic
1. Carson HJ. The medium, not the message: how tattoos correlate
with early mortality. Am J Clin Pathol. 2014;142:99-103.
2. Byard RW. Tattoos—forensic considerations. Forensic Sci
Med Pathol. 2013;9:534-542.
3. Cains G, Byard RW. The forensic and cultural implications
of tattooing. In: Tsokos M, ed. Forensic Pathology Reviews.
Vol 5. Totowa, NJ: Humana; 2008:197-220.
4. Byard RW. Ned Kelly tattoos—origins and forensic
implications. J Forensic Leg Med. 2011;18:276-279.
5. Byard RW, Charlwood C. Commemorative tattoos as
markers for anniversary reactions and suicide. J Forensic Leg
Med. 2014;24:15-17.