ABSTRACT
This work deals with the dating of Mount Etna lava flows and
eruptive fissure deposits to the last four millennia following field
investigations and stratigraphic data (BRANCA et alii, 2011a). We
have studied 24 of these volcanic products, including 301 large sam-
ples, through high precision archeomagnetic dating checked by
226
Ra-
230
Th radiochronology, thus providing additional material to
the previous paper by TANGUY et alii (2007). In most cases our
results allow attributing ages to the historical period, although two
flows are shown to be prehistoric. For the historic lavas, archeoma-
gnetic ages can be defined within decades, except for three of them
that erupted during a time span (Greco-Roman epoch) when the
geomagnetic field underwent little variation. Although 60% of these
volcanics exhibit ages comprised between 700 AD and 1850, only
one (1285) is mentioned by contemporary written accounts. We con-
clude that i) historical documents alone are insufficient to recon-
struct a coherent sequence of eruptions, and ii) a multidisciplinary
approach is necessary to obtain a comprehensive eruptive history of
such a very active volcano, useful for both scientific and civil protec-
tion purposes, even for such a geologically recent period as that of
the last 10 or 20 centuries. Thanks to these new archeomagnetic and
226
Ra-
230
Th data coupled with stratigraphic data, a comprehensive
volcanic history of the still-outcropping Mount Etna volcanics is
now available for the last 2,400 years.
KEY WORDS: Etna volcano, archeomagnetic dating,
226
Ra-
230
Th dating, stratigraphy, historical account.
INTRODUCTION
The “historical period” of Mount Etna spans almost
three millennia, and the popular belief is that eruptions of
the Sicilian volcano during this period are well-known.
This is not the case, however, because there are enormous
gaps in the historical documents due to wars, barbarian
invasions, and so on, or simply a lack of scientific interest
(for instance, there are no valuable accounts from 252 AD
to 1062, see TANGUY, 1981). Moreover, when going fur-
ther backwards in time, historical accounts are often
found to be unreliable and, above all, they are not precise
enough to identify the eruptive vents or spatial extension
of the lava flows. It thus follows that the size of eruptions
and even a rough estimate of the volume of volcanic pro-
ducts remain highly doubtful or unknown. Such data are
crucial for reconstructing the dynamics of the volcano
and for a statistical compilation of eruptions. High-preci-
sion archeomagnetism, combined with radiometric dat-
ing, has shown that 80% of the “historically dated” lava
flows prior to the 1700s were not produced by eruptions
quoted in the historical accounts, the discrepancies
reaching centuries and sometimes a millennium (TANGUY
et alii, 2003, 2007).
Starting in the 1990’s, a new detailed geological
survey was undertaken on Etna volcano by means of
updated stratigraphic criteria (BRANCA et alii, 2004, 2008)
with the aim of compiling the new geological map of
Italy (SERVIZIO GEOLOGICO D’ITALIA, 2009a,b,c and d).
Recently, these geological data were completed and
updated (BELLOTTI et alii, 2010) in order to publish the
new geological map of Etna volcano at 1:50.000 scale
(BRANCA et alii, 2011a). The volcanic products related to
the activity of the past 15 ka (Mongibello volcano) cover
about 88% of Etna edifice (BRANCA et alii, 2011b; DE
BENI et alii, 2011). During the making of the new geologi-
cal map, several Holocene tephra marker beds were used
to better constrain the age of the lava flows erupted in
this time span. In particular, the reconstruction of the
stratigraphic relationships between the lava flows and the
pyroclastic fall deposit of the 122 BC plinian eruption
(FG tephra layer of COLTELLI et alii, 1998, 2000) allows
the identification of the lava flow fields of unknown ages
erupted during the past 2,100 years. These new and
updated stratigraphic data have thereby completed the
historical record of Etna flank eruptions, in addition to
the data derived from historical sources existing since the
1600s (BRANCA & DEL CARLO, 2005; TANGUY et alii, 2007).
Indeed, the eruptions of the last 400 years (fig. 1) are well
known both in terms of deposits and eruption year except
for the lava flow named Dagala dell’Orso (BRANCA et alii,
2011a), located on the upper northwest slope (fig. 1a),
belonging to an eruption not reported in historical
sources. Conversely, the lava flows erupted before 1600
AD cannot generally be indicated by their eruption year,
except in rare cases when accurate historical data are
available. In particular, BRANCA et alii (2011a) have recog-
nised 35 lava flows between the 122 BC plinian eruption
and the 17
th
century. Only 7 of these lava flows have been
attributed to eruptions quoted in the historical sources,
corresponding to the years 1566, 1537, 1536, 1446, 1408,
1329 and 1285. Such lava flows were identified through a
critical examination of historical chronicles and checked
by archeomagnetic data (TANGUY et alii, 2007). The 1285
(*) Institut de Physique du Globe de Paris and CNRS - 94107
Saint-Maur des Fossés cedex, France.
(**) Université de Montpellier2 and CNRS - 34095 Montpellier
cedex 5, France.
(***) Istituto Nazionale di Geofisica e Vulcanologia, Osserva-
torio Etneo, Piazza Roma, 2 - 95125 Catania, Italy. Corresponding
authors: phone: +390957165800; e_mail: stefano.branca@ct.ingv.it
(****) Dipartimento di Scienze Geologiche, Università di Catania,
Corso Italia, 55 - 95129 Catania, Italy.
New archeomagnetic and
226
Ra-
230
Th dating of recent lavas
for the Geological map of Etna volcano
JEAN-CLAUDE TANGUY (*), MICHEL CONDOMINES (**), STEFANO BRANCA (***),
SANTO LA DELFA (****) & MAURO COLTELLI (***)
Ital. J. Geosci. (Boll. Soc. Geol. It.), Vol. 131, No. 2 (2012), pp. 241-257, 8 figs., 4 tabs. (doi: 10.3301/IJG.2012.01)
© Società Geologica Italiana, Roma 2012