The Wiley Blackwell Handbook of Humanism, First Edition. Edited by Andrew Copson
and A. C. Grayling.
© 2015 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Published 2015 by John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
20
This chapter considers the status and coherence of modern humanism as a
secular and ethical philosophy. As secular, humanism prioritizes the naturalistic
worldview, and privileges information from the social and cognitive sciences
about human sociality and morality. As ethical, humanism does more than rec-
ommend specific moral virtues and rules, by proposing methods to evaluate
moralities and recommend ideals of moral progress for all peoples around the
world. Humanism is not another moral code to add to the rest. As befits a
theoretical ‘ism’, humanism self‐reflectively asks why the world needs yet
another moral stance, and it philosophically defends its ethical position that
better moralities can be discriminated from worse.
Although morality is relative in the sense that it serves human needs and
varies somewhat depending on social circumstances, it would be a mistake to
categorize humanism as a kind of moral relativism. Moral relativism is one of
most talked‐about yet least understood notions around today. Despite what
one might hear, morality is neither a matter of taste nor preference, it is not
arbitrary or immune from criticism, and we don’t have to tolerate just any-
body’s moral opinions. No moral code of just one person, one culture, or even
one civilization is objectively worthy enough to be imposed universally upon
humanity. But it does not follow that human intelligence is not worthy of all
humanity. Morality can be objectively studied, morality can be rationally
debated and evaluated, there are justifiable ways to determine better and worse
moral norms, and important moral norms can be reasonably recommended for
all peoples. Systems of philosophical ethics take advantage of these intellectual
opportunities, and their efforts have enriched the life of our species. Embracing
simplistic moral relativism just to avoid unwise moral universalism rashly
abandons the noble striving for the ethical improvement of humanity.
Humanism, Moral Relativism,
and Ethical Objectivity
John R. Shook